Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

MONTANA ENTERTAINMENT, LLC
Las Vegas, NV

Representative

Shawn J Wallach
swallach@sphlaw.com
908-601-6550
100 West Pond Rd
Hopelawn, NJ 08861
Address should be: c/o The Haddad Law Firm, P.C., 2 Hance Ave., Tinton Falls, NJ 07724 732-933-3535, swallach@sphlaw.com
I. Respondent and Counsel Respondent: Montana Entertainment, LLC, c/o Siegelaub Rosenberg PA, 361 E. Hillsboro Blvd., Deerfield Beach, FL 33441. Counsel for Respondent: Shawn J. Wallach, Esq., The Haddad Law Firm, P.C., 2 Hance Ave., Tinton Falls, NJ 07724, 732-933-3535, swallach@sphlaw.com. II. Short Statement Disputing Facts Montana denies that it infringed any copyright of the Claimant and denies liability. Montana disputes any characterization of its use of “Nancy” as unauthorized or infringing. Montana admits that a sample of “Nancy” was used in the recording “Everything I Do” pursuant to a license and, as Claimant concedes, that the dispute concerns payment under that license, not infringement. Montana disputes the Claimant’s asserted damages. III. The Dispute and Montana's Defenses This is not an infringement claim. It is a dispute about payment under a fully executed license, which sounds in contract. Montana has not infringed the Claimant’s copyright for the following independent reasons. A. A fully executed, perpetual license authorizes the use. On July 12, 2022, New Stone Enterprises, Inc., as Licensor, and Montana Entertainment, LLC, as Licensee, executed a Master License granting Montana “the irrevocable, non-exclusive perpetual right and license” to use the “Nancy” sample in “Everything I Do” throughout the world. The agreement is signed by both parties, by Karim Kharbouch for Montana and by Washington Duke for New Stone. (Exhibit D.) The use is licensed, not infringing. B. “Nancy” is a joint work; a co-owner granted the license. The Copyright Office registration for “Nancy” (Reg. No. SR0001013340) identifies four joint authors: Kia Ifani Warren, Washington Alcebo Duke, Eric Simons, and Christopher Waller (Exhibit B). A co-author of a joint work is a co-owner who may license the work to others. A party holding a license from one co-owner is not liable to the other co-owners for infringement, and the co-owners’ remedy among themselves for any unpaid share is an accounting of profits, which is not infringement and is not a claim within the Board’s authority to adjudicate. See Oddo v. Ries, 743 F.2d 630, 632–33 (9th Cir. 1984). In addition to the Master License, Washington Duke, a co-owner, executed the master and publishing quote confirmations on June 29, 2022, the publishing confirmation being executed on behalf of the four publishing designees, including Blackbird Beach Visions (Exhibit C). C. The Claimant’s own Claim admits the license and frames the dispute as nonpayment. The Claim states that the co-authors of “Nancy” “signed over the use” of the work “via a master license agreement,” that they were “never paid the agreed upon amount to license the work,” and it seeks damages “for lack of timely payment.” These are admissions that a license was granted and that the grievance is nonpayment of the agreed fee. A dispute over the nonpayment of an agreed license fee is a contract matter, not copyright infringement (Exhibit A). D. Nonpayment does not revoke the license. Nonpayment of a license fee is a breach of the agreement, it does not automatically cancel the license. Graham v. James, 144 F.3d 229, 236–38 (2d Cir. 1998). The Master License grants the license irrevocably and in perpetuity, and no co-owner has ever served a notice of rescission or a takedown demand. E. Any payment obligation runs to the Licensor, not the Claimant individually. Paragraph 8 of the Master License provides that the licensor, New Stone Enterprises, Inc., “shall be solely responsible for paying any royalties, fees and/or payments due to the artist, producer or any other party who has or may have an interest in the Sample.” (Exhibit D). Consistent with that provision, New Stone invoiced the agreed consideration (Exhibit E). Montana’s payment obligation runs to New Stone, not to the Claimant individually. F. Independently, an implied license bars the claim. Even apart from the executed writings, the parties’ course of conduct, the clearance brokered through DMG, the invoicing of the agreed consideration, and years of continuous, undisputed distribution of “Everything I Do,” establishes at least an implied license to use the sample. G. Exceptions and limitations. To the extent the Claimant contends otherwise, Montana’s use is authorized by license as set forth above; Montana does not presently rely on the fair-use limitation of 17 U.S.C. § 107, and reserves all applicable exceptions and limitations under 17 U.S.C. §§ 107–122. H. Damages are capped and the Claimant’s demand is unsupported. Should the Board reach damages, exposure is limited. “Nancy” was first published on January 1, 2016, used in “Everything I Do” in June 2022, and not registered until October 2, 2024, after the alleged use began and outside the window under 17 U.S.C. § 412. For a work not timely registered, statutory damages “may not exceed $7,500 per work infringed, or a total of $15,000 in any 1 proceeding.” 17 U.S.C. § 1504(e)(1)(A)(ii). While the Claimant seeks $30,000, that figure is available only as actual damages, which must be proven, and the royalty and streaming record for the work will not support an award approaching that sum, or the statutory ceiling. Montana’s principal position remains that there is no infringement at all.