Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

John Bolger
Lunchbox Tattoo
Johnsburg, IL
Respondent completely denies all allegations of copyright infringement. The Claimant gave explicit consent and an implied non-exclusive license to use past and current studio photos for marketing, as proven by his manual and affirmative account interactions on the shop's social media feeds (Exhibit C) and a multi-year industry course of conduct (Exhibit F). Furthermore, this proceeding is a meritless, bad-faith retaliatory sham brought for an improper purpose to evade a documentable $1,400.00 commercial debt structure currently being adjudicated in parallel state court proceedings (McHenry County Circuit Court Case No. 2026SC001560). Pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 1506(y), Respondent respectfully requests a complete dismissal of the claim and a maximum statutory cost award of $2,500.00 for Claimant's systematic bad faith, administrative obstruction, and active concealment of material trial records. Respondent incorporates by reference his comprehensive attached file, 'Respondent_Master_Brief_and_Statement_of_Defenses.pdf', and supporting Exhibits A through O-2.
Claimant gave explicit consent and an implied non-exclusive license to use past and current studio photos for marketing, verified by his manual account interactions on the shop's social media feeds (Exhibit C) and a 10-year industry course of conduct (Exhibit F). See attached Master Brief.
Under 17 U.S.C. § 412, Claimant's late registration (nearly three years post-publication) strictly bars him from recovering statutory damages or attorney's fees, limiting him solely to actual economic losses, which are non-existent. See attached Master Brief. Under 17 U.S.C. § 412, Claimant's late registration (nearly three years post-publication) strictly bars him from recovering statutory damages or attorney's fees, limiting him solely to actual economic losses, which are non-existent. See attached Master Brief.
Unclean Hands and Retaliatory Bad Faith. This proceeding is a meritless sham brought for an improper purpose to evade a documentable $1,400.00 commercial debt currently being adjudicated in parallel state court proceedings (Case No. 2026SC001560). Respondent requests a bad faith cost award under 17 U.S.C. § 1506(y). See attached Master Brief.