Response to Request to Amend Scheduling Order

Go to case details
BEFORE THE COPYRIGHT CLAIMS BOARD UNITED STATES COPYRIGHT OFFICE John Bolger, Respondent, v. Andy J. Rivera, Claimant. Case No. 26-CCB-0018 RESPONDENT’S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO CLAIMANT’S REQUEST TO AMEND SCHEDULING ORDER Respondent John Bolger respectfully requests that the Board deny Claimant Andy J. Rivera’s "Request to Amend Scheduling Order" filed on November 3, 2026. Claimant has failed to demonstrate the mandatory showing of "good cause" required under 37 C.F.R. § 222.3, and his own text layout confirms pure administrative neglect. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT & BACKGROUND This Board entered its Amended Scheduling Order on September 8, 2026, setting a clear, hard discovery cutoff for November 6, 2026. As the Claimant who chose to initiate this $15,000.00 proceeding, Claimant bears the foundational burden to possess and have all supporting documentation organized prior to filing a claim. On October 7, 2026, Respondent fully complied with his discovery obligations by serving a complete set of standard interrogatories and document production requests directly to Claimant via email. Respondent provided Claimant with a full, standard 30-day window to complete and return his required disclosures. Claimant chose to sit in total silence for 25 days of that window, waiting until November 1, 2026, to request Respondent's consent to a 30-day extension. Respondent delivered an immediate, professional email rejection stating: "Andy, I do not consent to any extensions of the discovery deadline; the current schedule stands." ARGUMENT Under 37 C.F.R. § 222.3, scheduling modifications over a party's explicit objection require a showing of "good cause," which federal guidelines define as an unexpected emergency outside a party's control. Claimant's motion completely fails to meet this standard for two distinct reasons: 1. An Unexcused 11th-Hour Counsel Search Does Not Constitute Good Cause: Claimant explicitly admits in his motion that he has an initial case-review meeting scheduled with prospective attorneys on November 4, 2026—"only two days before the current discovery deadline." Claimant has had 56 full days since the September 8 scheduling order was posted to seek representation. Waiting until less than 72 hours before a major discovery cliff to finally consult an attorney is a direct result of Claimant's own procedural neglect, not an emergency. 2. Admission of an Evidentiary Void: Claimant confesses that he requires an extension to "verify, organize, and accurately complete my discovery responses and document production." Claimant has had nearly two months to organize his files. Respondent is a small business owner who has meticulously followed every board rule and timeline; Respondent is legally entitled to finality and should not be forced to extend this litigation into the holiday season because Claimant failed to prepare his case. CONCLUSION Because Claimant's own filing proves that his unpreparedness is entirely self-inflicted, Respondent respectfully requests that the Board flatly deny Claimant's request and maintain the hard discovery exchange deadline for Friday, November 6, 2026. Dated: November 3, 2026 Respectfully submitted, John Bolger, Respondent Pro Se
  • John Bolger