Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

Orest Melnyk
d/b/a OMA COMP
Royal Oak, MI

RESPONDENT'S RESPONSE TO CLAIM

Respondent Orest Melnyk (d/b/a OMA Comp) submits this response to the claim for copyright infringement filed by Claimant Mariusz P. Nowak in the above-captioned proceeding, Docket No. 26-CCB-0425.

I. Preliminary Statement

Respondent disputes liability and asks the Board to dismiss this claim. Claimant alleges that OMA Comp publicly displayed eight photographs from the group registration titled “A Polish Retro-Style Dance (Zabawa w Stylu PRL)” (Reg. No. VA0002508996, effective June 14, 2026) on OMA Comp’s Facebook page between June 9 and June 16, 2026. Respondent shows below that the images were originally posted by the American Polish Cultural Center (APCC) with Claimant’s permission, that OMA Comp reposted the images in the ordinary course of its longstanding work supporting and promoting APCC events, and that OMA Comp removed the images promptly upon learning that Claimant objected — all before Claimant’s copyright registration for the images had even taken effect.

II. Statement of Facts

Source of the Images. The photographs at issue were first posted publicly by APCC on APCC’s own Facebook page, with Claimant’s permission, following the event held on or about June 9, 2026. OMA Comp has served as a sponsor and promotional supporter of APCC events for approximately seven years. Consistent with that longstanding relationship, OMA Comp reposted a number of the APCC images on OMA Comp’s own Facebook page to help promote and support the event, under the good-faith understanding that APCC-sourced event content could be shared for that purpose.

Notice and Removal. Respondent first learned that Claimant objected to the reposting on or about June 15, 2026, and that Claimant had not personally authorized OMA Comp’s use of the images. Respondent promptly attempted to contact APCC to clarify the scope of APCC’s permission, and, out of an abundance of caution, removed all of the images from OMA Comp’s social media and website by no later than June 16, 2026, within one (1) day of learning of Claimant’s objection and before this claim was filed.

Direct Outreach to Claimant. On June 17, 2026, Respondent personally emailed Claimant to apologize for the misunderstanding, confirm that the photographs had already been taken down, explain that the reposting had occurred in connection with Respondent’s longstanding support for APCC and its events, and acknowledge that any authorization APCC received did not extend to OMA Comp (see attachment “2nd-Ehhibit_A_Re_ Notice of Copyright Infringement.pdf”). In that email, Respondent asked to speak with Claimant directly to better understand his concerns and the basis for the invoiced amount, and to work toward an amicable resolution. Claimant did not take up that invitation, and this claim followed instead.

Registration Timing. Claimant’s registration for the group of photographs, VA0002508996, has an effective date of June 14, 2026. The infringement period alleged in the claim begins June 9, 2026, five days before that effective date.

Damages Demand. Claimant states that he invoiced OMA Comp $800 ($100 per image, later reduced to the total of $600, then increased by arbitrary late fee to $700). Respondent disputes that this figure is not reasonable value for a short-duration, non-commercial, good-faith repost of event-promotion photographs among community partners.  It appears that this was the first time Claimant filed a copyright for any photographs he took.

III. Respondent's Position and Defenses

●        Good-faith, non-willful conduct. Respondent's use was not willful. OMA Comp reposted images that had already been made public by APCC, believed in good faith that doing so was consistent with its long-running role in supporting APCC events, and took the images down within one day of learning that Claimant objected.

●        Before this claim was filed, Respondent personally reached out to Claimant by email on June 17, 2026, apologized for the misunderstanding, confirmed the images had been removed, and requested a call to discuss and resolve Claimant's concerns, including the basis for the invoiced amount. This outreach is inconsistent with any suggestion of bad faith and supports a favorable view of Respondent's conduct and any request for costs or fees.

●        Scope of APCC's permission. Claimant's own submission states that the photographs were posted by APCC “solely for APCC's use,” but does not address whether APCC was authorized to permit its sponsors, contractors, or supporters, including OMA Comp, to repost APCC event content in connection with promoting APCC's events. Respondent requests that Claimant clarify, and intends to seek confirmation directly from APCC, what rights APCC held and conveyed regarding downstream use of the images by its partners.

●        Registration timing. Respondent notes that the alleged infringement period (beginning June 9, 2026) predates the effective date of Claimant's copyright registration (June 14, 2026) and preserves any defenses or limitations on remedies that may be available on that basis.

●        Identification of images at issue. Claimant's submission lists eight individually titled photographs. Respondent has not yet confirmed which, if any, of those eight specific images actually appeared on OMA Comp's Facebook page, as opposed to APCC's page, and requests that Claimant identify the specific URLs and dates corresponding to each image he contends was reposted by OMA Comp.

●        No unjust enrichment or bad faith. OMA Comp did not sell the photographs, did not use them beyond a limited promotional repost tied to a community event it has long supported, and removed them voluntarily upon notice. Respondent submits that this conduct does not support a finding of bad faith by OMA Comp and reserves the right to seek an award of costs and fees if the Board finds that this proceeding was pursued in bad faith.

IV. Requested Relief

For the reasons above, Respondent respectfully requests that the Copyright Claims Board:

●        Dismiss the claim in its entirety; or, in the alternative,

●        Limit any award to reflect only those specific images, if any, shown to have actually been reposted by OMA Comp, the brief duration of any such use, OMA Comp's good faith, and its prompt voluntary removal of the images upon notice; and

●        Grant such other relief as the Board deems just and proper.

V. Reservation of Rights

Respondent reserves all rights, defenses, and objections available under the Copyright Claims Board's rules and procedures, including the right to supplement this response as the record develops, including through the discovery and merits-conference process.

Claimant's own submission states that the photographs were posted by APCC “solely for APCC's use,” but does not address whether APCC was authorized to permit its sponsors, contractors, or supporters, including OMA Comp, to repost APCC event content in connection with promoting APCC's events. Respondent requests that Claimant clarify, and intends to seek confirmation directly from APCC, what rights APCC held and conveyed regarding downstream use of the images by its partners.

OMA Comp did not sell the photographs, did not use them beyond a limited promotional repost tied to a community event it has long supported, and removed them voluntarily upon notice. Respondent submits that this conduct does not support a finding of bad faith by OMA Comp.