Claim Response
Filed date: 11/09/2026 02:38 PM EST
United States Copyright Claims Board
Claim Response
Response details
Representative
Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067
This dispute concerns the use of the audiovisual work titled The Art Of Gacha War (the “Subject Video”) authored by Claimant/Counter-Respondent Bao Kaiwen p/k/a MrPokke (“Claimant”) in the critique video titled The Tragic Downfall of MrPokke (the “Critique Video”) authored by Respondent/Counterclaimant Sun “Steven” Ho Yu p/k/a Saintontas (“Respondent”).
For ease of reference, the Subject Video is being uploaded as Exhibit 1 and the Critique Video is uploaded as Exhibit 2.
Background of the Parties and Events Leading Up to the Subject Video
Claimant and Respondent are online content creators whose content focuses on a genre of videogames called “gacha” games. Gacha games are role-playing/strategy games that employ a “freemium” business model – i.e., the game can be downloaded for free but players make in-game purchases for randomized items. The game’s “gacha system” refers to the structure of using currency earned in-game or through in-game purchases to acquire new items or features. It also includes how necessary it is to make in-game purchases, what is obtained by in-game purchases and how often valuable items are received.
There are many gacha games. Online content creators who focus on gacha games tend to focus on a single game. Claimant’s content focuses on the game titled Honkai: Star Rail and games developed by HoYoverse. Respondent’s content focuses on the game titled Wuthering Waves by a separate developer, Kuro Games. Sometimes, Claimant and Respondent will comment about other gacha games and their gacha systems.
Prior to the creation of the Subject Video, Claimant began making content on the gacha game Arknights: Endfield. In this content, Claimant effusively praised the game and its gacha system. Claimant received significant criticism from the gacha community (including from Respondent) for Claimant’s support of Arknights: Endfield – as the gacha community viewed the game’s gacha system as highly predatory. Additionally, numerous gacha game creators (including Respondent) publicly criticized Claimant as shilling for Arknights: Endfield.
On January 17, 2026, Respondent created a nearly half-hour video titled I’m Disgusted. In the video, Respondent criticized Claimant (and other gacha game creators) who promoted Arknights: Endfield and defended its predatory gacha system.
On January 18, 2026, Respondent created a video titled MrPokke Sold Out. In the over thirty-minute video, Respondent made more directed and pointed critiques of Claimant’s support of Arknights: Endfield.
The Subject Video and Critique Video
On January 19, 2026 (i.e., the day after Respondent made his second video about Claimant), Claimant released the Subject Video. The Subject Video was twenty minutes and forty-two seconds (20:42). In the Subject Video, Claimant attempted to address the criticisms levied against him for his support of Arknights: Endfield.
The Subject Video primarily focused on the criticisms levied by Respondent against Claimant. While not referring to Respondent by name, the Subject Video contains numerous visual references of Respondent, including: (1) using the thumbnails for Respondent’s videos MrPokke Sold Out and I’m Disgusted, albeit distorted with graphical effects (Ex. 1, beginning at 1:25); (2) showing an image of Respondent (Ex. 1, beginning at 2:19); (3) separately showing the thumbnail for Respondent’s video I’m Disgusted (Ex. 1, beginning at 7:49); and (4) parodying Respondent’s criticisms from the I’m Disgusted video (Ex. 1, beginning at 14:47).
Sometime after the Subject Video was released, Respondent reacted to the Subject Video during a livestream. Approximately twelve hours after the Subject Video was released, Respondent uploaded the Critique Video – which was an edited version of Respondent’s livestream reaction to the Subject Video that removed dead air for brevity.
The Critique Video was one hour, twenty-two minutes and twelve seconds (1:22:12). In the Critique Video, Respondent played brief portions of the Subject Video followed by extended commentary by Respondent of the excerpt shown. For most of the excerpts shown from the Subject Video in the Critique Video, the Subject Video was played at a faster than normal speed – as Respondent was solely interested in addressing Claimant’s critiques that were contained in the Subject Video.
In total, Respondent’s Critique Video provided 1:05:45 of commentary on the content of the Subject Video – i.e., 80% of the Critique Video was comprised of Respondent’s commentary. In total, only 16:27 or 20% of the Critique Video comprised of the Subject Video and only 88% of the original was shown.
Events Leading Up to Claimant’s Issuance of the DMCA Takedown and Claimant’s Issuance of the DMCA Takedown
Claimant was embroiled in a public controversy in the days leading up to him issuing his DMCA takedown of the Critique Video (“Claimant’s DMCA Takedown” or “DMCA Takedown”). This public controversy – including Respondent’s participation in the public critique of Claimant for this controversy – contextualize why Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown of the Critique Video over two weeks after the Subject Video and Critique Video were published and views for both videos were nascent.
On February 6, 2026, Claimant’s former editor publicly released a Google doc that detailed allegations of abuse by Claimant against the former editor. In a now deleted video, Claimant said he would retaliate against anyone who reacted to the document.
On February 8, 2026, Respondent reacted to the former editor’s Google doc during his livestream. Later that evening, Respondent released an edited version of his reaction to the Google doc in a video titled MrPokke’s Career is Over.
The same day that Respondent released the Mr. Pokke’s Carrer is Over video critiquing Claimant, Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown of the Critique Video. On February 12, 2026, YouTube processed Claimant’s DMCA Takedown, removed the Critique Video and informed Respondent of Claimant’s DMCA Takedown. YouTube did not forward the actual contents of Claimant’s DMCA Takedown. See Exhibit 3 (PDF Printout of YouTube’s Email to Respondent); Exhibits 4-5 (screenshots of details provided by YouTube when clicking the “View Details” button in Exhibit 3).
Claimant’s Terms for Withdrawal of his DMCA Takedown
Shortly after it became public on February 12, 2026 that Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown against Respondent for the Critique Video, Claimant made a livestream where he discussed his DMCA Takedown and his terms for initiating negotiations to retract his DMCA Takedown. On February 13, 2026, Claimant uploaded an edited version of his February 12, 2026 livestream in a video titled The Tragic Downfall of Saintontas’ Career (“2/13/26 Video”). See Exhibit 6 (the 2/13/26 Video from 31:47-33:50).
Specifically, in Claimant’s 2/13/26 Video, Claimant pulled up his February 11, 2026 post on X that contained certain terms to resolve their public dispute. Claimant adopted those terms as preconditions for negotiating the retraction of his DMCA Takedown. Those terms were: (1) a public apology on Respondent’s main channel; (2) Respondent removing all videos about Claimant; and (3) never mentioning Claimant again. See Exhibit 6 at 31:47-33:50; Exhibit 7 (Claimant’s February 11, 2026 Post on X).
Respondent Submits his Counternotification
On February 17, 2026, Respondent (through counsel) submitted his counternotification to Claimant’s DMCA Takedown. The counternotification contained a detailed analysis of why the Critique Video made a fair use of the Subject Video and briefly explained why Claimant’s DMCA Takedown was a violation of 17 U.S.C. § 512(f). See Exhibit 8 (PDF Printout of Counternotification).
Factor One: The purpose and character of the Critique Video’s use of the Subject Video weighs heavily in favor of fair use. The entire purpose of the Critique Video was to methodically comment on and criticize each point raised in the Subject Video.
The Critique Video’s structure demonstrates how it achieves a diametrically opposite purpose than the original. In the Critique Video, Respondent consistently plays a brief excerpt from the Subject Video, pauses it and provides extensive criticism and commentary on the excerpt shown.
On a more granular level, Respondent played excerpts from the Subject Video ranging from 2 seconds to 28 seconds – with most being under 10 seconds. Respondent paused the Subject Video 95 times to provide his commentary, which ranged from a few seconds to over three minutes at a time. In total, the Subject Video comprised 16:27 minutes of the 1:22:12 Critique Video (i.e., 20% of the Critique Video). The amount of Respondent’s criticism and commentary on the Subject Video comprised 1:05:45 of the 1:22:12 Critique Video (i.e., 80%). In other words, the ratio of Respondent’s commentary on the Subject Video relative to the amount of the Subject Video used in the Critique Video was 4:1. This is not a scenario where gratuitous portions of the Subject Video were used in the Critique Video without criticism or comment. Even Claimant conceded this point in his 2/13/26 Video where he admitted that Respondent provided an “additional one hour of commentary” on the Subject Video. Ex. 6 at 31:19-31:27.
The nature of Respondent’s criticism further emphasizes the Critique Video’s critical purpose. If one were to excise the excerpts shown of the Subject Video from the Critique Video, Respondent’s commentary would lose context and effectiveness. Rather, since Respondent’s criticisms have a direct critical bearing on the content of Subject Video, the excerpts used from the Subject Video are necessary to understand Respondent’s commentary of the Subject Video. This is not a scenario where Respondent’s commentary was unrelated to the Subject Video or would otherwise retain its effectiveness without reference to the Subject Video.
Finally, the extent of Respondent’s criticism of the Subject Video in the Critique Video is so great that it eclipses any potential commercial use by the placement of ads on the Critique Video. As such, these facts demonstrate that the first fair use factor weighs heavily in favor of fair use.
Factor Two: The nature of the Subject Video also weighs in favor of fair use. First, the Subject Video was publicly disseminated on Claimant’s YouTube channel. When a copyright owner exhausts their right to control the first public appearance of the work, this fact will weigh in favor of fair use.
Second, the Subject Video is not a work of fiction or fantasy. Rather, it is primarily informational – as it contains Claimant’s opinions and responses to criticism levied against him. As such, the informational nature of the Subject Video also weighs in favor of fair use.
Factor Three: The quantitative and qualitative amount of the Subject Video used in the Critique Video was reasonably necessary to achieve the Critique Video’s highly critical purpose. As discussed in the context of the first fair use factor, by showing a brief excerpt of the Subject Video, pausing it and providing extensive commentary on the excerpt shown, the structure of the Critique Video’s commentary on the Subject Video demonstrates that the amount used was reasonably necessary for Respondent’s critique of the Subject Video. This is not a scenario where gratuitous portions of the Subject Video were used without comment. Nor was this a scenario where the Critique Video’s commentary was unrelated to the Subject Video. As discussed in the context of factor one, the excerpts shown from the Subject Video contextualize Respondent’s criticisms and are necessary to understand Respondent’s criticisms.
Factor Four: The Critique Video’s use of the Subject Video did not (and cannot) result in legally cognizable market harm to the Subject Video. Copyright only protects the economic interests of the author in the exploitation of the work; it does not protect the reputational interests of the author, which is why the law does not recognize legally cognizable market harm from criticism.
Claimant repeatedly admitted that any purported harm resulted from Respondent’s criticism – not financial harm to the Subject Video because the Critique Video served as a substitute. Below are some quotes proving this point:
· “He literally just used other creators’ content in the absolute fucking worst faith possible and abuse[d] the previously established good faith ever since Genshin Impact. Because for Saintontas [i.e., Respondent], reacting to an original content doesn’t just help his growth; he is just a guy critiquing; he just [wants] to insult, insinuate that ‘I am providing fair criticism, therefore, it falls under fair use’ right – but on top of that – you are actively putting down the creator you’re stealing from by saying: ‘Ah, man, This guy’s trash. All right. This guys reputation should be burned to the fucking ground.’” Ex. 6 at 20:24-21:13.
· “The stealing of others content. And not only just that, you steal it and you scream and shout and insult the person you’re literally stealing from.” Ex. 6 at 19:07-19:18.
· “Imagine having so much confidence, so much happiness that you farmed me, slandered me, went after my editors, went after my community for the past one year.” Ex. 6 at 3:34-3:55.
· “So, by definition, right, Saintontas’ [i.e., Respondent’s] entire existence – I’m just going to say as it is – it is literally being a parasite. It is worse than being a red[?] because he cannot have any originality for majority of all his content – aside from critiques. Aside from critiques, right. He can only critique, he can only steal, he can only put down, encourage hate.” Ex. 6 at 22:37-23:04
In essence, Claimant effectively concedes that his “copyright” claim is a reputational injury claim in disguise. This is emphasized by the “terms” Claimant imposed as preconditions to negotiate the withdrawal of his DMCA Takedown – i.e., publicly apologize to Claimant, remove all content on Respondent’s channel referring to Claimant and never speak about Claimant again. Exhibit 6 at 31:47-33:50; Exhibit 7 (Claimant’s February 11, 2026 Post on X).
Further emphasizing Claimant’s “copyright” claim is a reputational injury claim in disguise is the timing of Claimant’s DMCA Takedown. Both the Subject Video and Critique Video were publicly released on January 19, 2026. Claimant waited until February 8, 2026 – i.e., over two weeks later – to issue his DMCA Takedown. After two weeks, the demand for a YouTube video is nominal at best. Rather, the timing of Claimant’s DMCA Takedown was because Respondent discussed Claimant’s public controversy with his former editor on February 8, 2026 – i.e., the same day Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown.
Claimant also misrepresents his “evidence” in support of market harm. The “Before Traffic” exhibit shows other videos that recommended the Subject Video – i.e., a thumbnail for the Subject Video appeared alongside the videos contained in the exhibit. To begin, Claimant does not provide the date of this screenshot. Further, none of the videos identified belong to Respondent; rather three are Claimant’s videos and two belong to unrelated third-party creators. Contrary to Claimant’s assertions, this evidence does not demonstrate that there was an existing overlap in audience between Claimant and Respondent prior to the Subject Video.
The “After Traffic” exhibit undermines Claimant’s assertion of market harm. The screenshot shows that the Subject Video was recommended to people who watched the Critique Video. This is logical because Critique Video is a response to the Subject Video. Further, the exhibit demonstrates that individuals who watched the Critique Video subsequently watched the Subject Video – which refutes the existence of market harm or that the Critique Video served as a substitute for the original.
The lack of market harm is further emphasized by the “Shared Audience” screenshot. To begin, the screenshot does not encompass the time period when the Subject Video and Critique Video were publicly released (i.e., January 19, 2026). As shown in the top right corner, the information applies only to the “Last 28 days” which encompassed “Jan 29-Feb 25, 2026.” During this time period, Claimant made numerous videos about Respondent (and vice versa) because the time period encompassed Claimant’s public controversy with his editor, Respondent’s video’s on the controversy, Claimant publicly announcing his DMCA Takedown and Respondent publicly announcing his counternotification. At most, this showed that Respondent’s audience was watching Claimant’s content to follow the drama. It does not support the assertion that viewers of the Critique Video watched it as a substitute for the Subject Video. To the contrary, if these analytics did encompass January 19, 2026, it would support the assertion that Respondent’s audience watched Claimant’s Subject Video – which refutes any market harm.
Far more telling is Respondent’s March 13, 2026 screenshot of channels his audience watched that encompassed the last 28 days – i.e. February 13, 2026 to March 13, 2026. See Ex. 9 (screenshot of YouTube analytics of channels Respondent’s audience watched taken on March 13, 2026). The time period for the screenshot encompassed Claimant’s 2/13/26 Video and Respondent’s video announcing he submitted a counternotification to Claimant’s DMCA Takedown. Despite there being drama between Claimant and Respondent during that time period, Claimant did not make it into the top five of other creators Respondent’s audience also watched.
Finally, there can be no market harm because the Critique Video provided a completely different viewing experience from the Subject Video because the critique video transformed the Subject Video into fodder for caustic, moment-by-moment commentary and mockery.
Arising Out of Same Transaction or Occurrence: Respondent’s counterclaim for misrepresentation under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) arises from Claimant’s DMCA Takedown for the Critique Video. Since Claimant’s copyright infringement claim arises from his allegation that the Critique Video infringed the Subject Video, Claimant’s allegations of copyright infringement and Respondent’s claim of misrepresentation arise from the same transaction or occurrence.
Summary of Counterclaim: The basis of Respondent’s counterclaim is that Claimant misrepresented in his DMCA Takedown whether he formed a good faith belief about whether the Critique Video made a fair use of the Subject Video prior to issuing his DMCA Takedown. Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown to punish Respondent for discussing Claimant’s public controversy with his former editor and not due to any alleged copyright infringement. Additionally, Claimant’s statements demonstrate that he did not review the Critique Video to make a fair use determination prior to issuing his DMCA Takedown.
Prior Factual Allegations Incorporated by Reference: Many of the facts relevant to Respondent’s counterclaim are discussed in greater detail above. To avoid unnecessary repetition, Respondent shall summarize the material facts below:
- From January 17-18, 2026, Respondent made two videos criticizing Respondent.
- On January 19, 2026, Claimant made the Subject Video to address Respondent’s criticisms.
- Shortly thereafter, Respondent commented on and criticized the Subject Video in a live stream and subsequently uploaded an edited version of the critique on YouTube (i.e., the Critique Video).
- Claimant did not issue a DMCA takedown of the Critique Video at that time.
- On February 6, 2026, Claimant became embroiled in a public controversy when his former editor released a document detailing Claimant’s abuse of the former editor. Claimant threatened to take action against anyone who would review the document.
- On February 8, 2026, Respondent made a livestream and subsequent video that commented on the document released by Claimant’s former editor.
- The same day, Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown of the Critique Video, which was over two weeks after the release of the Subject Video and Critique Video.
- On February 13, 2026 (and after Claimant’s DMCA Takedown became public), Claimant stated in the 2/13/26 Video that he would consider negotiations to remove his DMCA Takedown if Respondent publicly apologized to Claimant, removed all videos mentioning Claimant and never speak about Claimant again. Further, in the 2/13/26 Video that purported to explain why Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown, Claimant focused on the reputational injuries Respondent allegedly inflicted upon Claimant and not any financial injury.
Claimant’s CCB Complaint: The complaint that Claimant filed with the CCB further emphasizes that Claimant did not review the Critique Video prior to issuing his DMCA Takedown. In the complaint, Claimant states that: “Respondent seldomly pauses” the Subject Video. The Critique Video refutes this assertion – as it was paused on no less than 95 occasions for Respondent to provide commentary.
Claimant also states that “Respondent plays Claimant’s copyrighted video through nearly its entire runtime, stopping only seldomly to insert brief commentary.” This is demonstrably false. As mentioned, the Critique Video is 1:22:12. The Critique Video comprises 16:27 of the Critique Video (i.e., 20%). The remaining 1:05:45 (i.e., 80%) comprised of Respondent’s commentary on the Subject Video.
Claimant also states that Respondent’s “added commentary is incidental” – which is refuted by the fact that the ratio of the commentary provided on the Subject Video in the Critique Video to the Subject Video is 4:1.
YouTube
YouTube does not forward DMCA takedowns to the users subject to the DMCA takedown. Rather, YouTube will notify the user via email that a DMCA takedown has been submitted. The email will contain: (1) the title of the video subject to the DMCA takedown; (2) the URL for the video subject to the DMCA takedown; (3) the title of the work allegedly infringed; (4) where the allegedly infringed work is located in the video subject to the DMCA takedown; (5) the person/entity requesting the takedown; and (6) the email address (or other contact information) for the party issuing the takedown. See e.g., Ex. 3.
On February 12, 2026, YouTube sent Respondent an email informing him that Claimant issued “a copyright removal request” for Respondent’s “video” and “[b]ased on applicable copyright law,” YouTube “removed” the video. Ex. 3. The email also contained the following information (emphasis is in the original):
Video title: The Tragic Downfall of MrPokke
Video url: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bn2A0ie2TN4
Content used: The Art of Gacha War
Content found in: Entire video
Removal request issued by: MrPokke
Contact info: [email protected]
A true and correct copy of the counternotification is submitted as Exhibit 8. For convenience, the content of the counternotification is being pasted below.
To whom it may concern:
Full Legal Name: Rom Bar-Nissim. Attorney for the YouTube channel: Saintontas. I am authorized by Saintontas to submit this counternotification on his behalf. As proof of authorization, Saintontas is included on this email.
Physical Mailing Address: Heah Bar-Nissim LLP, 1801 Century Park East, Suite 1800, Los Angeles, California 90067.
Telephone Number: (310) 432-2836
URL for the Saintontas Video Subject to DMCA Takedown: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bn2A0ie2TN4
Legal Statements:
Consent to Jurisdiction: Saintontas consents to jurisdiction of the Federal District Court for the district in which he is located (Northern District of California, San Francisco Division) which is also the district in which YouTube is located, and my firm (as the authorized agent of Saintontas) will accept service of process from the claimant.
Affirmation: Saintontas swears, under penalty of perjury, that he has a good faith belief that the material was removed or disabled as a result of mistake or misidentification of the material to be removed or disabled.
Statement by Claimant:
The video by Saintontas entitled The Tragic Downfall of MrPokke (the “Critique Video”) made a fair use of the video by claimant MrPokke entitled The Art of Gacha War (the “Subject Video”). Below is Saintontas’ analysis explaining why the Critique Video makes a fair use of the Subject Video under each of the four fair use factors under 17 U.S.C. Section 107.
As to the first fair use factor, the Critique Video transforms the Subject Video by directly criticizing the style and substance of the Subject Video. See Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, 598 U.S. 508, 528 & 545 (2023) (quoting 17 U.S.C. § 107; citing Authors Guild v Google, Inc., 804 F.3d 202, 215-216 (2d Cir. 2015)); see also Hosseinzadeh v. Klein, 276 F.Supp.3d 34, 41-42, 45-46 (S.D.N.Y. 2017). More specifically, the purpose of the Subject Video is MrPokke addressing criticism Saintontas and others made of MrPokke and his support of the game Arknights: Endfield and its gacha system. Indeed, the Subject Video repeatedly references Saintontas by: (1) showing an image of Saintontas (Subject Video at 02:19); (2) showing the thumbnail of Saintontas’ video I’m Disgusted where he levies his criticisms against Arknights: Endfield and MrPokke shilling for the game (Subject Video at 7:49); and (3) parodying Saintontas’ criticisms in the I’m Disgusted video (Subject Video at 14:47). Further, in a video made on February 13, 2026 (the “2/13/26 Video”), MrPokke admits that the Subject Video was directed at Saintontas (link to video)
In the Critique Video, Saintontas directly engages with, addresses and refutes the arguments Mr. Pokke makes in the Subject Video about Saintontas – along with critiquing Mr. Pokke himself. Saintontas structures his critique by playing a few seconds of the Subject Video, pausing and then provide his criticism of the portion played for a duration significantly longer than the clip shown from the Subject Video. This structure of: (1) playing a clip from the original video; and (2) providing commentary on the clip shown that eclipses the duration of the clip from the original has consistently been held to be transformative – which weighs strongly in favor of fair use. Hosseinzadeh, 276 F.Supp3d at 45-46; Stebbins v. Alphabet Inc., 2025 WL 2233208, *4-5 (N.D. Cal. July 2, 2025).
Critically, Mr. Pokke publicly admitted (albeit unwittingly) that the Critique Video made a highly transformative use of the Subject Video. In the 2/13/26 Video, MrPokke expressly concedes: (1) the Critique Video provided an additional one hour of commentary to the 20 minute Subject Video (timestamped link); and (2) the Critique video repeatedly criticized MrPokke and the points he made in the Subject Video (timestamped links 1, 2, 3, 4, 5) Therefore, even MrPokke concedes that Saintontas’ Critique Video made a highly transformative use of the Subject Video.
As to the second fair use factor, the Subject Video was publicly disseminated prior to the Critique Video and is primarily informational – which also weighs in favor of fair use. See Monge v. Maya Magazines, Inc. 688 F.3d 1164, 1178 (9th Cir. 2012); McGucken v. Pub Ocean Ltd., 42 F.4th 1149, 1161 (9th Cir. 2022).
As to the third fair use factor, the amount and substantiality the Critique Video used of the Subject Video was reasonably necessary for Saintontas’ critique of the Subject Video. See Hosseinzadeh, 276 F.Supp.3d at 46; Mattel, Inc. v. Walking Mountain Productions, 353 F.3d 792, 803-804 (9th Cir. 2003). Here, the Critique Video uses most (but not all) of the Subject Video to critique the contents of the Subject Video and MrPokke. Even if the Critique Video used the entirety of the Subject Video (which it did not), using the entirety of a copyrighted work can still constitute a fair use. See e.g., Mattel, 353 F.3d at 803-804; Swatch Group Management Services Ltd. v. Bloomberg L.P., 756 F.3d 73, 89-90 (2d Cir. 2014). This applies with equal force to YouTube reaction videos that critique the original. See Stebbins, 2025 WL 2233208, *6.
The reasonableness of the use is readily apparent by watching the Critique Video. The Critique Video will play a few seconds from the Subject Video and surround it with significantly longer commentary and criticism on the clip previously played. See Hosseinzadeh, 276 F.Supp.3d at 46. Without using the clips from the Subject Video, the Critique Video’s commentary and criticism of the Subject Video would lose all context and utility. Id. Therefore, the third fair use factor favors fair use because the amount Saintontas used of the Subject Video in the Critique Video was reasonably necessary for the critique.
As to the fourth fair use factor, there is no legally cognizable market harm resulting from the Critique Video’s criticism of the Subject Video or of Mr. Pokke. Campbell, 510 U.S. at 591-592; Hosseinzadeh, 276 F.Supp.3d at 46-47. Copyright only protects the author’s financial interests in the work – not the reputational or privacy interests of the author. Garcia v. Google, Inc., 786 F.3d 733, 745-746 (9th Cir. 2015).
Further, it is readily apparent that the Critique Video does not (and cannot) serve as a market substitute for the original. Hosseinzadeh, 276 F.Supp.3d at 46-47 Rather, anyone watching Subject Video will have a very different experience watching Critique Video, which responds to and transforms the Subject Video into fodder for caustic, moment-by-moment commentary and mockery. Id.
MrPokke effectively concedes that there was no market harm to the Subject Video from the Critique Video. Rather, MrPokke admits his objective is to silence Saintontas’ criticism of him and punish Saintontas for making that criticism. This is evidenced MrPokke’s February 11, 2026 Twitter post at 10:00 a.m. PST offering to retract the DMCA takedown if Saintontas: (1) makes “A Public Apology on his main channel”; (2) “Remov[es] all videos about me”; and (3) “Never mentioning me ever again.” (Link to Tweet). This was reiterated in the 2/13/26 video (timestamped link) and the statements discussed above in the context of the first fair use factor. Taken together, the fourth factor heavily weighs in favor of fair use.
To conclude, the Critique Video makes an obvious fair use of the Subject Video.
It is equally obvious that MrPokke engaged in misrepresentation as defined by 17 U.S.C. Section 512(f) by sending an abusive takedown notification to silence criticism and failing to conduct the proper analysis to form a subjective good faith belief that Critique Video’s use of the Subject Video was infringing. See Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., 815 F.3d 1145, 1154-1155 (9th Cir. 2015). As discussed above, MrPokke admits that the Critique Video provided extensive criticism and commentary on the Subject Video and the only harm was to MrPokke’s reputation – not the Subject Video. Also discussed above is MrPokke’s desire to punish and silence Saintontas for his criticism. Issuing a DMCA takedown for the purpose of silencing an admitted fair use is the very definition of misrepresentation under 17 U.S.C. Section 512(f).
Therefore, Saintontas respectfully requests that YouTube restore the Critique Video pursuant to 17 U.S.C. Section 512(g)(2)(C).
As discussed above, YouTube does not forward the exact contents of a DMCA takedown. However, to qualify as a DMCA takedown under 17 U.S.C. § 512(c)(3)(A), the party issuing a DMCA takedown must make a “statement that the complaining party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.” 17 U.S.C. § 512(c)(3)(A)(v). To satisfy this requirement, the party issuing the DMCA takedown must consider fair use to comply with the requirement that the use “is not authorized [by] the law.”
Therefore, the misrepresentation contained in Claimant’s DMCA Takedown is the statement required under 17 U.S.C. § 512(c)(3)(A)(v). The reason why this constitutes as a misrepresentation is that – for the reasons set forth in the description of the counterclaim – Claimant did not form a good faith belief whether the Critique Video constituted fair use prior to issuing his DMCA Takedown. Respondent alleges that Claimant: (1) did not review the Critique Video to form a good faith belief whether the Critique Video constituted fair use prior to issuing his DMCA Takedown; and (2) Claimant issued his DMCA Takedown in bad faith as a reputational injury claim in disguise to retaliate against Respondent for discussing Claimant’s public controversy with his ex-editor that same day.
The most immediate economic injury was that Respondent was forced to retain counsel to respond to Claimant’s DMCA Takedown with a counternotification and retain defense counsel for this proceeding.
Further, Claimant’s DMCA Takedown – along with publicizing his DMCA Takedown – resulted in an individual submitting another fraudulent DMCA takedown against Respondent. After Claimant’s DMCA Takedown became public, Claimant publicized this fact and that – if Respondent received two more DMCA takedowns – YouTube would permanently delete Respondent’s channel. See Exhibit 10 (Screenshots of comments to the 2/13/26 Video and online posts discussing getting Respondent’s YouTube channel terminated by issuing DMCA takedowns).
On February 24, 2026 (i.e., a few days after Claimant publicized his DMCA Takedown in the 2/13/26 Video), YouTube notified Respondent that it received a DMCA takedown claiming that Respondent used music in one of his videos without authorization. This was patently false because Respondent had licensed the music for free from YouTube’s Audio Library. Additionally, the name of the party issuing the DMCA takedown was different from the person identified as the author of the music used by Respondent. As a result, Respondent had to retain counsel to issue another counternotification – which received no further response. See Exhibit 11 (YouTube’s February 24, 2026 email notifying Respondent of the second DMCA takedown); Exhibit 12 (screenshots of the license); Exhibit 13 (counternotification to second DMCA takedown).
Further injury resulted from receiving two copyright strikes from YouTube. For context, YouTube’s repeat infringer policy is that, for each DMCA takedown, the recipient will receive a copyright strike. If the user receives three DMCA takedowns within a 90 day period, YouTube will terminate the account. Claimant’s fraudulent DMCA Takedown – along with the fraudulent DMCA takedown inspired by Claimant’s DMCA Takedown – put Respondent’s channel on the brink of termination for no good reason.
Additionally, after receiving the copyright strikes, Respondent’s views and revenue on YouTube suffered. When a YouTube channel receives copyright strikes, YouTube’s algorithm will limit the visibility of that YouTube’s creator’s content. Immediately after YouTube processed Claimant’s DMCA Takedown on February 12, 2026, Respondent received less views – which resulted in less revenue. Respondent’s views only recovered until the copyright strikes were removed several months later. See Exhibit 14 (Analytics for Respondent’s YouTube Channel before and after YouTube processed Claimant’s DMCA takedown).
- Download Ex. 1 - The Subject Video (The Art of Gacha War.).mp4 (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 3 - YouTube Notification of Claimant's DMCA Takedown to Respondent.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 4 - Screenshot of View Details Webpage for DMCA Takedown (Part 1).png (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 5 - Screenshot of View Details Webpage for DMCA Takedown (Part 2).png (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 6 - The Tragic Downfall of Saintontas' Career..mp4 (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 7 - Screenshot of Claimant's Tweet Containing Terms.jpeg (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 8 - Counternotification to DMCA Takedown.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 9 - 2026.3.13 - Screenshot of Overlap in Audience.png (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 10 - Comments from Claimant's Video Announcing DMCA Takedown.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 11 - Second DMCA Notification.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 12 - Screenshots of License.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 13 - Second Counternotification.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 14 - Respondent's Analytics.pdf (Opens new window)
- Download Ex. 2 - Critique Video (file size condensed).mp4 (Opens new window)