Amended Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

Alex Pagan
Tulsa, OK

Representative

Christopher J Gnaedig
cgnaedig@hallestill.com
918-594-0597
521 East 2nd St., Suite 1200
Tulsa, OK 74120

Representative

John Richer
jricher@hallestill.com
918-808-4999
521 East 2nd Street
Tulsa, OK 74120

Representative

John Richer
jricher@hallestill.com
918-594-0400
521 East 2nd Street
Tulsa, OK 74120

Representative

Robert Fitz-Patrick
rfitzpatrick@hallestill.com
918-625-2430
521 E 2nd Street
Suite 1200
Tulsa, OK 74120
Claimant, Kenny McKee’s (“McKee”) claims in this matter are merely complaints of a disgruntled former employee who wishes to cause harm to his prior employer. Respondent, Alex Pagan d/b/a Humble Performance (“Humble”), an automotive garage and performance tuning shop, hired McKee for the specific purpose of managing Humble’s marketing—including its social media pages—and production of videos uploaded to Humble’s YouTube channel. Humble paid McKee $1,000 per week to perform those services, plus 50% of the monetization that Humble received from YouTube. Although McKee was engaged as an independent contractor, he performed this work expressly and exclusively for Humble and, prior to this dispute, never claimed an ownership interest in the product created for Humble. Under the work for hire doctrine, Humble is the author of these works and owns all of the rights comprised in the copyright. There is no written instrument between Humble and McKee to the contrary. In mid-late 2025, Humble elected to terminate its relationship with McKee. Around this time, McKee drafted that certain Settlement, Licensing, Product Transfer, and Non-Disparagement Agreement dated August 22, 2025 (the “Agreement”). A full and complete copy of the executed Agreement is attached. While the Agreement’s title includes references to “licensing” and “product transfers,” as McKee admits in his Claim, the final, executed version of the Agreement does not include any provisions to that effect (note that sections 2 and 3 of the Agreement were deleted before execution). This is because Humble refuted McKee’s outlandish claims that he ever owned any of the videos or other product he created for Humble. Under the Agreement, Humble agreed to pay McKee the sum of $14,000 in severance compensation over a period of 18 weeks. The purpose of these payments was to provide McKee sufficient funds to pay taxes he had failed to pay on the income he received while working for Humble, to resolve outstanding disputes between the two regarding wages, tax treatment, and intellectual property, and to secure the parties’ mutual agreement to refrain from harming each other’s reputation. Critically, Section 5 of the Agreement contains a broad mutual release of claims: "Except for obligations created by this Agreement, each party fully releases the other from any and all claims, demands, or liabilities of any nature, known or unknown, arising prior to the effective date. This release specifically includes, without limitation, claims related to: wages, severance, benefits, intellectual property, employment classification, contracts, and state or federal tax obligations." As of the Effective Date of the Agreement, the subject videos were featured on Humble’s YouTube channel, and Humble understood that it was the owner of such media. Accordingly, in entering into the Agreement, McKee fully released any claim against Humble that the videos constituted McKee’s intellectual property. The Agreement further provides that it is "the entire agreement between the parties and supersedes all prior oral or written understandings" and that all amendments "must be in writing and signed by both parties." Accordingly, McKee's allegations of a "verbal agreement to finalize a deal to license the works for commercial use" is entirely without merit.
Under the work-for-hire doctrine, as set forth in 17 U.S.C. § 201(b): "In the case of a work made for hire, the employer or other person for whom the work was prepared is considered the author for purposes of this title and, unless the parties have expressly agreed otherwise in a written instrument signed by them, owns all of the rights comprised in the copyright." As the Copyright Act does not define "employee" or the "scope of employment," courts apply common law agency principles to determine if a work constitutes work-for-hire under the Act. Importantly, courts recognize that a non-W-2 employee may constitute an employee for purposes of the work-for-hire doctrine. Although he did not receive benefits and did not receive a W-2, McKee worked exclusively for Humble, who controlled the manner and means by which the videos were accomplished; Humble had the ultimate say in how a video was filmed and produced and whether it should be uploaded to Humble’s YouTube channel. The videos did not require a high degree of skill, as they are, for the most part, simple recordings with limited post-production work. The videos were filmed almost exclusively at Humble’s shop, with some shots taken at the racetrack. McKee was paid a set salary of $1,000 per week for his work—regardless of how many videos he created during the week—in addition to receiving a commission of 50% of the monetization revenue received from YouTube. Taking all these factors into consideration, a court would surely find McKee qualifies as an employee for purposes of the work-for-hire doctrine. And as there was no writing signed by the parties to the contrary, any work McKee created as a Humble employee belongs to Humble.
Even if the works did not fall within the work-for-hire doctrine, as discussed above, McKee released any claims to the subject works pursuant to Section 5 of the Agreement.
As discussed above, Humble owns the copyright to the subject works pursuant to the work-for-hire doctrine.
As discussed above, McKee waived, released, and settled any claims to the subject works pursuant to Section 5 of the Agreement. McKee was already paid to create these works as a Humble employee and cannot recover again for performing that work.
Respondent, Alex Pagan d/b/a Humble Performance (“Humble”)'s counterclaim for misrepresentation against Claimant, Kenny McKee ("McKee") relates to the same subject works at issue in McKee's claim. Humble, an automotive garage and performance tuning shop, hired McKee for the specific purpose of managing Humble’s marketing—including its social media pages—and production of videos uploaded to Humble’s YouTube channel. Humble paid McKee $1,000 per week to perform those services, plus 50% of the monetization that Humble received from YouTube. Although McKee was engaged as an independent contractor, he performed this work expressly and exclusively for Humble and, prior to this dispute, never claimed an ownership interest in the product created for Humble. Under the work for hire doctrine, Humble is the author of these works and owns all of the rights comprised in the copyright. There is no written instrument between Humble and McKee to the contrary. In mid-late 2025, Humble elected to terminate its relationship with McKee. Around this time, McKee drafted that certain Settlement, Licensing, Product Transfer, and Non-Disparagement Agreement dated August 22, 2025 (the “Agreement”). A full and complete copy of the executed Agreement is attached. While the Agreement’s title includes references to “licensing” and “product transfers,” as McKee admits in his Claim, the final, executed version of the Agreement does not include any provisions to that effect (note that sections 2 and 3 of the Agreement were deleted before execution). This is because Humble refuted McKee’s outlandish claims that he ever owned any of the videos or other product he created for Humble. Under the Agreement, Humble agreed to pay McKee the sum of $14,000 in severance compensation over a period of 18 weeks. The purpose of these payments was to provide McKee sufficient funds to pay taxes he had failed to pay on the income he received while working for Humble, to resolve outstanding disputes between the two regarding wages, tax treatment, and intellectual property, and to secure the parties’ mutual agreement to refrain from harming each other’s reputation. Critically, Section 5 of the Agreement contains a broad mutual release of claims: "Except for obligations created by this Agreement, each party fully releases the other from any and all claims, demands, or liabilities of any nature, known or unknown, arising prior to the effective date. This release specifically includes, without limitation, claims related to: wages, severance, benefits, intellectual property, employment classification, contracts, and state or federal tax obligations." As of the Effective Date of the Agreement, the subject videos were featured on Humble’s YouTube channel, and Humble understood that it was the owner of such media. Accordingly, in entering into the Agreement, McKee fully released any claim against Humble that the videos constituted McKee’s intellectual property. The Agreement further provides that it is "the entire agreement between the parties and supersedes all prior oral or written understandings" and that all amendments "must be in writing and signed by both parties." Accordingly, McKee's allegations of a "verbal agreement to finalize a deal to license the works for commercial use" is entirely without merit. Despite Humble’s clear ownership of these works, McKee wrongfully submitted dozens of DMCA takedown requests to YouTube and Facebook that ultimately resulted in removal of several of Humble's Facebook videos and the suspension and demonetization of Humble's YouTube channel, which historically ranged from several hundred dollars to over $1,200 per month. YouTube further advised Humble that the nature of the suspension of its channel disallows Humble from creating a new channel in the future.
Kenny McKee
YouTube and Facebook
Various dates beginning in September 2025
Misrepresentations regarding ownership of the subject works.
Yes
Alex Pagan
YouTube and Facebook
Various dates beginning in September 2025
Explanation of Humble Performance's true ownership of the subject works.
McKee knowingly misrepresented to these platforms that he is the owner of the subject works, all of which are owned by Humble for the reasons set forth herein.
As a result of McKee’s infringement of Humble’s work, Humble no longer receives income from its monetized social media pages, including Facebook and YouTube, which historically ranged from several hundred dollars to over $1,200 per month.