Amended Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

justin brown
West Palm Beach, FL
My name is Justin Mj Brown, and my phone number is 305-565-0867. My address is 1262 Via Panzai, Boynton Beach, FL 33426
I categorically deny Claimant’s allegation that I copied, derived, or created “YOU DO YOU” from his work. “YOU DO YOU” originated with me. I independently created and recorded it, and I possess an original recording that I contend dates to approximately September 2020 containing the disputed material. Claimant’s own amended claim and evidence fail to establish that I had access to his alleged work before I created mine. Claimant alleges that he privately created material while incarcerated in 2019. I had no knowledge of, access to, or opportunity to hear or view anything allegedly written or kept privately by Claimant while he was incarcerated. Claimant identifies no communication, transmission, publication, shared file, recording, or other path by which I could have obtained that alleged material before creating my September 2020 recording. Claimant relies upon a MyFreeCopyright record dated January 30, 2021. That date is after the September 2020 recording I will produce. The statement contained in that private third-party record asserting creation during incarceration in 2019 does not establish that I ever possessed or had access to that alleged material. More importantly, Claimant’s own exhibit does not establish any pre-September-2020 access by me. Claimant further alleges that his work became publicly available beginning February 12, 2021. That allegation directly undermines his access theory as it relates to the creation of my work. A work allegedly made publicly available in February 2021 cannot establish that I copied it when my recording containing the disputed material already existed months earlier in September 2020. Claimant also relies upon a later video and communications as supposed evidence of access. Those communications occurred only after my work already existed. My later awareness of Claimant or his song cannot retroactively establish that I had access to his work before independently creating mine. Claimant is attempting to use later events to prove earlier copying, but those events do not establish the required chronology. I also reject Claimant’s assertion that similarity proves that his work was the source of mine. The disputed lyrics, vocal performance, delivery, cadence, structure, and other material embodied in my recording originated with me and were independently created and recorded by me. Claimant’s assertion of similarity does not cure the absence of evidence showing that I accessed his alleged work before creating mine. Claimant’s evidence showing that I subsequently uploaded or distributed “YOU DO YOU” through YouTube, SoundCloud, TikTok, or digital music services likewise does not establish infringement. Those later uploads are distributions of the same independently created work. Evidence that I continued releasing my own song years later does not prove that I copied Claimant when I originally created it. Claimant also mischaracterizes the parties’ later agreement. The agreement was not the source of my right to create or own “YOU DO YOU,” and I did not ask Claimant for permission to create or own my song. My song already existed. The later discussions concerned the collaborative remix and the terms under which Claimant could use the disputed material. I communicated the terms of that arrangement, including that my separate version remained my own, that Claimant was not to repost or re-release his separate version, and that the version involving me would be an approved collaborative remix featuring me. Claimant’s reliance on the later document titled “12/10/2021 Agreement | Partnership” is also disputed. The particular Google Drive item later produced shows that it was created and edited by The Purple Snake Era on October 11, 2022, not created as that particular Drive item in December 2021. I did not edit that October 2022 document; I only viewed it. It should not be treated as the original December 2021 agreement merely because it was given a title containing a December 2021 date. The original December 2021 communications and agreement materials must be evaluated separately from that later-created document. Claimant’s copyright registration, cease-and-desist letter, copyright complaints, and other later assertions of ownership prove that Claimant has asserted a claim against me; they do not prove that I copied him. The central factual defect in Claimant’s infringement theory remains unchanged: Claimant has not established that I had access to his alleged work before I independently created and recorded “YOU DO YOU.” I did not copy Claimant’s work. I did not derive “YOU DO YOU” from Claimant’s work. The disputed material in my recording originated with me. Claimant’s own chronology places the access events on which he relies after my work already existed. I therefore deny his allegations of copying, unauthorized use, and copyright infringement and request that his claim be denied.
I independently created and fixed my song “YOU DO YOU” without copying Claimant’s work. I specifically deny hearing, seeing, receiving, or otherwise having access to Claimant’s protected work before creating my own song. I possess an original recording that I contend dates to approximately September 2020, together with independently dated 2021 evidence documenting my work, including SoundCloud, YouTube, distribution, social-media/platform records, and my copyright registration. Claimant alleges that he wrote a version of his material in a notebook while incarcerated in 2019. Even accepting that allegation for purposes of this response, the existence of material in a private notebook does not establish that I knew about it or had access to it. Claimant has not established how I could have seen, heard, received, or otherwise obtained material that, according to his own account, existed privately in a notebook while he was incarcerated. My own work, by contrast, was independently recorded and subsequently documented and posted publicly through social-media and music platforms. Claimant’s assertion that he created something earlier does not establish that I copied it. Earlier creation and access are separate issues, and I specifically dispute having access to Claimant’s protected expression before creating and fixing my own work. Any alleged similarities must therefore be evaluated together with the actual chronology, the evidence concerning access, and my independently created recording. Similarity alone does not change my position or establish that my work was derived from Claimant’s work.I therefore deny that “YOU DO YOU” was copied from, derived from, or created using Claimant’s copyrighted work and maintain that it was independently created by me.
I assert this defense only in the alternative and do not concede that I needed Claimant’s permission to create or release my independently created “YOU DO YOU” work. During the parties’ later discussions concerning the remix, Claimant agreed to the terms I proposed for how the releases would be handled. He agreed that I would maintain and release my own version, and that he would not repost or re-release his separate version, but would instead release only a collaborative remix featuring me that I approved. The parties’ agreement therefore placed limits on Claimant’s own use and release of the disputed material and distinguished my original version from any approved remix. To the extent Claimant now seeks damages based on conduct covered by that arrangement, the agreement limits or defeats the damages he seeks. This defense does not concede that Claimant owned my original work or that I transferred ownership of my original version to him.
1. Background and independent creation I, Justin Brown, dispute Claimant Hakeem D. Pugh’s allegation that I copied protected material from his work “Imma Let You Go.” I maintain that I independently created and recorded the disputed musical material in approximately September 2020, before I had access to the work Claimant now alleges I copied. My original recording and subsequent online publication history support my account of independent creation. Claimant contends that he created his material in 2019 and first published it on February 12, 2021. I dispute his allegation that I copied his work and rely on my original recordings, dated publications, and communications in support of my position. 2. My documented publication history I possess a SoundCloud notification dated July 18, 2021, at approximately 3:05 a.m., identifying my track “YOU DO YOU (prod. Soullex)” and notifying me that another user liked the track. This notification establishes that my recording was already available and receiving engagement on SoundCloud by July 18, 2021. Claimant’s SoundCloud page identifies a September 14, 2021 upload of his recording titled “Imma Let You Go.” My July 18 SoundCloud evidence therefore predates that particular September 14 upload by approximately two months. I recognize that Claimant asserts earlier creation and publication dates. The SoundCloud evidence specifically documents my earlier online availability relative to his identified September upload. My sound recording “YOU DO YOU” was subsequently registered with the United States Copyright Office under Registration No. SR 914-738, effective December 2, 2021. The certificate identifies me as the author and copyright claimant, lists 2021 as the year of completion, and identifies September 11, 2021 as the first publication date of the registered work. I submit the registration as evidence of my registered recording and its documented publication chronology. 3. Viral TikTok and Claimant’s access My musical performance also circulated through TikTok, including a widely viewed video associated with my account @jit_2_slight. A preserved screenshot identifies a July 6 posting date and displays approximately 1.5 million views and 23,800 shares. The complete original post will be used to verify its publication year and contents. This demonstrates the substantial public circulation reflected in the screenshot. More importantly, Claimant personally acknowledged becoming aware of my TikTok. On December 8, 2021, Claimant sent me an email concerning our disputed works. In that communication, he stated that after releasing his full version, he realized I had posted a TikTok containing material he considered coincidentally similar to his work. Claimant also stated that he had recognized me, given me credit, and added me to a revenue split. These statements are significant because they demonstrate Claimant’s actual awareness of my TikTok and recognition of similarities between the disputed works, rather than relying solely on the possibility that he could have encountered my work online. I identify the widely circulated TikTok described above as the video I believe Claimant was referencing. The December 8 correspondence establishes his awareness by that date. It does not establish the precise date of his first access, and Claimant maintained that the similarities were coincidental. 4. Claimant’s performance and public acknowledgment I possess evidence showing Claimant publicly performing or publishing disputed lyrical material that I contend originated in my earlier work. An Instagram publication dated October 27, 2021, associated with @hakeemprimequotes contains the disputed passage beginning “Imma let you go cause I need my peace.” Claimant’s commercial release “Imma Let You Go” also publicly identifies both Hakeem Prime and Justin Brown as lyricists in Pandora’s songwriting credits. This attribution is relevant because it identifies me as a credited contributor to the lyrics of the release involved in Claimant’s allegations. The credit does not independently establish exclusive ownership or the precise circumstances under which the lyrics were created. I request that it be considered with the earlier recordings, communications, and publication history. 5. Subsequent communications and remix arrangement The parties subsequently discussed a collaborative remix involving my work “YOU DO YOU.” My understanding was that the arrangement concerned the specifically approved collaborative recording and did not transfer ownership of my independently created original recording. In December 2021, Claimant discussed acknowledgment, mechanical licensing, credits, and revenue sharing. I rely on these communications to establish the history of the parties’ interactions, the acknowledgment of my contribution, and the circumstances surrounding the disputed musical material. Any question concerning the effect of an agreement should be evaluated according to its actual terms and the uses involved. 6. Relationship to Claimant’s infringement allegations Claimant alleges that the disputed material originated with him and that I improperly copied it. My position is that I independently created my material and did not copy Claimant’s protected expression. The parties’ competing accounts concern the origin and performance of the disputed lyrical and musical passage, their respective recordings, the chronology of publication, subsequent communications, and the scope of any permissions. My September 2020 recording, July 2021 SoundCloud evidence, copyright registration, Claimant’s September 2021 upload, December 2021 correspondence, and the public songwriting credits are relevant to evaluating those competing accounts. 7. Requested consideration I respectfully request that the Copyright Claims Board consider the documented creation and publication chronology, original recordings, relevant communications, and commercial credits when evaluating Claimant’s allegations against me. I dispute Claimant’s assertion that I unlawfully copied his protected work. I maintain that my work was independently created and that the available evidence should be evaluated according to the dates, contents, and circumstances of the parties’ respective recordings and publications. I reserve my applicable defenses and request that Claimant’s infringement allegations be decided on the evidence presented in this proceeding.
YOU DO YOU
Justin Brown
Yes
SR914738
12/02/2021
Sound recordings
Sound recording of “YOU DO YOU,” including my recorded vocal performance, delivery, cadence, and the sounds embodied in the recording.
Publicly display the work
Publicly perform the work
Create a derivative work
Reproduce the work
Distribute copies of the work
Yes
07/06/2021 - Present
Online, including YouTube, where the unauthorized music video was published, and digital music streaming/distribution platforms where the song and sound recording were reproduced, released, and distributed.
The Claimant acknowledged in writing that he became aware of my TikTok content relating to “You Do You.” I did not know Hakeem Prime at the time of the earlier events he describes, and I had no relationship or communication with him at that time. On September 25, 2021, The Purple Snake Era independently contacted me through SoundCloud regarding “You Do You,” asking whether the song was on Spotify and requesting my email address. At that time, I did not know who Hakeem Prime was and believed The Purple Snake Era was a label or music-industry outlet independently contacting me about my music. I did not understand that communication to be a request from Hakeem Prime or on his behalf. I later submitted “You Do You” to The Purple Snake Era and was subsequently informed that the track had been added to playlists. The Claimant later communicated with me concerning the songs and our respective versions. In a December 8, 2021 email, the Claimant acknowledged that he had seen my TikTok, had given me credit in connection with the song, had added me to a split, and stated that he was willing to publicly characterize his version as a cover. I did not authorize the Claimant to own my copyrighted work, release a separate personal version using my protected material, or incorporate my protected recording into an independently released music video. I allege that his reproduction, distribution, release, and other exploitation of my protected work outside the specifically authorized remix exceeded the scope of the permission I provided.
No
The harm from the Claimant’s alleged infringement was substantial and extended beyond a single song or release. The repeated copyright disputes and takedown activity arising from the unauthorized use of my work disrupted my ability to distribute, monetize, and continue building my music career. DistroKid ultimately stopped serving as my distributor, and I could no longer continue releasing music normally under the established artist name through which I had built my audience and catalog. I was forced to change my artist name and effectively rebuild my music career under a new identity, losing continuity with the audience, recognition, catalog history, and momentum I had already developed. This represented a significant economic loss. My distribution records show approximately 7.4 million streams and more than $40,000 in earnings attributed to my established artist identity, MJ 5ou1. My music had become a meaningful and recurring source of income, not merely a hobby. Losing the ability to distribute and monetize music normally under that established identity substantially reduced my ability to earn from my catalog and future releases. The loss of music income became significant enough that I had to obtain additional employment to replace income that music had previously provided. I also lost the opportunity to fully benefit from the success and momentum of “You Do You” while dealing with copyright disputes, distribution problems, and the disruption of my established artist identity. I contend that the Claimant’s unauthorized exploitation of my copyrighted work materially contributed to these financial and career-related losses. I seek all monetary relief available through the Copyright Claims Board, including compensation for proven lost music income and other actual economic damages, any profits attributable to the Claimant’s infringement, or statutory damages if elected and available. I ask the Board to consider the full financial impact on my distribution relationship, established artist identity, catalog, audience, earning capacity, and ability to continue commercially exploiting my copyrighted work.