Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

POLMEDIA, LLC
SEGUIN, TX

Representative

Marcin Papiez
marcin@polmedia.com
512-363-0083
425 Still Meadow Road
Seguin, TX 78155

POLMEDIA, LLC does not dispute that the photograph appeared in an informational blog article on its website in 2023. However, Respondent disputes Claimant's characterization of the duration, intent, continued use, and value of the alleged infringement.

The article was created by an employee as informational content about Poland. The employee obtained the photograph from a third-party travel website and referenced the source from which it was obtained. Respondent did not purchase a license from Claimant, and the photograph was not sold, licensed, or offered as a product by Respondent.

Respondent first became aware of an objection to the use in October 2023. Upon receiving notice, Respondent removed the blog article and ceased its intentional public-facing use of the photograph.

Respondent later learned that the underlying image file had inadvertently remained in the WordPress media directory. After removal of the blog, the image was no longer linked from or displayed as part of Respondent's public-facing blog or other website content and apparently could only be reached through its specific direct media URL. Respondent was not aware that the underlying file remained accessible and did not knowingly or intentionally continue using or promoting the photograph.

Respondent therefore disputes Claimant's characterization that the complained-of use continued continuously through the present. Claimant's submitted materials do not, on their face, establish continuous public accessibility of the direct media URL throughout the period alleged.

Respondent also disputes the $15,000 damages demand and Claimant's asserted licensing valuation as disproportionate to the limited nature and circumstances of the use. The photograph appeared only in an informational blog article, the blog was removed after notice, and Respondent did not knowingly or intentionally continue using the photograph thereafter.