Claim Response
Filed date: 07/06/2026 02:15 PM EDT
United States Copyright Claims Board
Claim Response
Response details
Respondent Misty Thompson created a series of YouTube videos discussing and reviewing the Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch between approximately January 29, 2025, and February 18, 2026, on the YouTube channel “Maggie Thompson Under the Veil.” The series consisted of two categories of content: (1) prerecorded reading for discussion videos addressing individual “Keys” or topics from the book, and (2) live commentary and review broadcasts containing Respondent’s analysis, criticism, opinions, and educational discussion regarding the text and its teachings.
The prerecorded reading for discussion videos were uploaded as unlisted videos and were not publicly promoted as standalone entertainment or substitute copies of the book. The live broadcasts remained public and primarily consisted of commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and Respondent’s personal analysis of the material.
Throughout the series, Respondent identified the work and author by name and discussed the material in the book in context of review and education. Respondent’s commentary was independently created and reflected Respondent’s own interpretations, criticisms, and opinions regarding the text. Each video included in the introduction that it is JJ Hurtak (author)’s work, and multiple times throughout he would be credited. (Attribution in the form of transcript, and video evidence can be provided as well).
In late 2025, Respondent received an informal communication indicating that portions of the reading videos might raise copyright concerns. After receiving a formal YouTube copyright notice on or about February 16, 2026, Respondent promptly removed the prerecorded reading videos from YouTube, removed thumbnails and images derived from the text, and submitted a counter notification regarding the remaining commentary and review content.
On or about March 3, 2026, YouTube notified Respondent that the counter notification was accepted and that the identified videos were restored in accordance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.
At present, no publicly available videos on Respondent’s channel contain extended verbatim readings of the text, full-page reproductions of copyrighted images, or large continuous excerpts from the work. The remaining publicly available videos consist of commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and limited quotation in the course of review.
Response to Allegations
Respondent acknowledges that certain prerecorded videos created during the course of the series included readings from portions of The Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch and limited display of images contained within the text. Those prerecorded reading videos were separate from Respondent’s live commentary and review broadcasts and were later removed from YouTube by the Respondent following receipt of the February 2026 copyright notice.
Respondent denies, however, that the currently available videos on the channel constitute ongoing full-text reproduction or unauthorized duplication of the work as characterized in the Claim. The remaining public videos primarily consist of Respondent’s own commentary, criticism, educational discussion, analysis, and review, with limited quotations used in the context of discussing and evaluating the material.
Respondent further denies that the content was created by copying Claimant’s YouTube content or seminars. Respondent independently created the videos using Respondent’s own copy of The Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch and Respondent’s own interpretations and commentary regarding the text. Respondent did not reproduce Claimant’s channel content, lecture recordings, or seminar presentations.
Respondent further notes that the Claim states the work was used “without attribution.” Respondent consistently identified the book and author during the videos and discussed the material openly as part of a book review and educational discussion series. While attribution does not determine whether infringement occurred, the allegation that the material was presented without identifying the work or author is inaccurate (Attribution and video evidence can be provided as well).
Following notice of the copyright concerns, Respondent acted promptly and in good faith by removing the prerecorded reading for discussion videos, removing thumbnails and images derived from the text, and limiting remaining public content to commentary and review material.
Mitigation and Good Faith Actions
Respondent took prompt steps to address copyright concerns once formal notice was received through YouTube in February 2026. Prior to the formal notice, the prerecorded reading for discussion videos had already been maintained as unlisted videos rather than broadly promoted public uploads.
After receipt of the YouTube copyright notice on or about February 16, 2026, Respondent promptly removed the prerecorded reading for discussion videos from YouTube and removed thumbnails and images derived from The Book of Knowledge: Keys of Enoch. Respondent also reviewed the remaining public content and limited publicly available videos to commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and review material.
Respondent submitted a counter notification regarding the remaining commentary/review content on February 17, 2026. On or about March 3, 2026, YouTube restored the identified videos after reviewing pursuant to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act process.
Respondent has continued to maintain the distinction between removed reading material and remaining commentary/review material. At present, Respondent is not publicly displaying videos containing extended verbatim readings, full-page image reproductions, or large continuous excerpts from the work.
These actions were taken voluntarily and in good faith in an effort to address concerns raised by Claimant while preserving Respondent’s ability to engage in commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and review.
Revenue and Alleged Harm
Respondent disputes Claimant’s characterization that Respondent used the material for significant commercial exploitation or “paid creative advertising” causing meaningful economic harm.
The prerecorded reading videos identified in the Claim generated $0.00 revenue. The remaining commentary and review videos collectively generated approximately $3.43 in total advertising revenue over the course of the series. Respondent did not use the videos to sell copies of The Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch, redistribute the text commercially, or operate a substitute distribution platform for the work.
The publicly available commentary/review videos consist primarily of Respondent’s own discussion, criticism, interpretation, and educational commentary regarding the subject matter of the book. Respondent’s channel is not affiliated with Claimant, and Respondent did not represent the videos as authorized reproductions, official teachings, seminars, or substitute copies of the work.
Respondent further notes that the prerecorded reading videos referenced in the Claim were removed after notice, and that no publicly available videos currently contain extended verbatim readings, full-page image reproductions, or large continuous excerpts from the work.
To the extent Claimant alleges ongoing infringement or substantial economic harm, Respondent disputes those allegations as overstated and unsupported by the actual scope, revenue, and current status of the content at issue.
Defense and Objections
Respondent asserts that the remaining publicly available commentary and review videos constitute protected commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and review, including limited quotation used for purposes of analysis and discussion regarding The Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch (See attached Fair Use for Education notification that is included in each commentary video).
Respondent further asserts that Claimant’s allegations improperly combine materially different categories of content into a single characterization of ongoing infringement. The prerecorded reading videos identified in the Claim were removed following notice, while the remaining public videos differ substantially in purpose, character, and content and consist primarily of Respondent’s own commentary, criticism, and analysis.
Respondent objects to Claimant’s characterization that Respondent copied Claimant’s seminars, lectures, or YouTube content. Respondent independently created the videos using Respondent’s own copy of the text and Respondent’s own interpretations, criticisms, and commentary. Respondent did not reproduce Claimant’s channel uploads, seminar recordings, or proprietary audiovisual content.
Respondent further disputes any allegation of willful or bad-faith infringement. Upon receiving formal notice through YouTube, Respondent acted promptly to remove prerecorded reading videos, remove associated thumbnails and images, and maintain only commentary/review material that Respondent understood to constitute permissible discussion, criticism, and educational review.
Finally, Respondent objects to any claim of substantial commercial exploitation or significant damages. The videos at issue generated little to no revenue, and Respondent did not operate the channel as a substitute source for the copyrighted work or as a commercial redistribution platform for Claimant’s content.
Requested Relief
Respondent respectfully requests that the Copyright Claims Board consider the limited scope of the disputed material currently available online, Respondent’s prompt good-faith actions following notice, the minimal revenue associated with the videos, and the distinction between removed prerecorded reading videos and the remaining commentary/review content.
Respondent further requests that the Board consider that no publicly available videos currently contain extended verbatim readings, full-page reproductions of copyrighted images, or large continuous excerpts from The Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch, and that the remaining content consists primarily of commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and review.
To the extent the Claim alleges ongoing infringement, substantial commercial exploitation, copying of Claimant’s seminars or audiovisual content, or significant economic harm, Respondent disputes those allegations.
Respondent respectfully requests dismissal of claims relating to the remaining commentary and review content and requests that any consideration of damages reflect Respondent’s prompt mitigation efforts, limited use, minimal revenue, and good-faith conduct throughout the matter.
Respondent Misty Thompson created a series of YouTube videos discussing and reviewing the Book of Knowledge: The Keys of Enoch between approximately January 29, 2025, and February 18, 2026, on the YouTube channel “Maggie Thompson Under the Veil.” The series consisted of two categories of content: (1) prerecorded reading for discussion videos addressing individual “Keys” or topics from the book, and (2) live commentary and review broadcasts containing Respondent’s analysis, criticism, opinions, and educational discussion regarding the text and its teachings. The live broadcasts primarily consisted of commentary, criticism, educational discussion, and Respondent’s personal analysis of the material.