Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

Hey Ricochet, Inc.
Buda, TX

Representative

Andrea Stein
heyricochet.co@gmail.com
650-235-6061
6700 Zequiel Drive
Austin, TX 78744
We, Andrea Stein and Cayce Matteoli, jointly own and operate the company Hey Ricochet, Inc. where we design and sell hair accessories. In or around May of 2024, we designed a collection of fantasy and literature inspired accessories which included our Fairy Wing Hair Comb design (the Hey Ricochet Design). This collection became available to customers on August 22nd, 2024. Four days later, on August 26th, 2024, we received an email from Angela Jarman purporting that our design was infringing on the copyright for her Titania Fairy Wings design and giving us 48 hours to remove the product listing from all platforms. We had no knowledge of Jarman or her business prior to receiving this email, and had never visited her social media profiles or website. Believing our design to be unique from Jarman’s, we responded to this email on August 29th, 2024 stating that we would consult with counsel on how to move forward. On September 7th, 2024, Jarman filed a DMCA Takedown Notice for the Hey Ricochet Design on our website. We responded to this notice on the same day. On September 9th, 2024, while we were in the process of finding and getting an opinion from a copyright attorney, Jarman filed her initial CCB suit for infringement (Docket 24-CCB-0271). Because of this active case, we did not respond to her directly. After the initial suit was dismissed in January of 2025 due to Jarman not filing proof of service with the CCB, Jarman filed a second suit on January 8th, 2025. In the months leading up to this claim being filed, Jarman took multiple steps to harm our business and reputation: writing a blog post detailing her claims that included personally identifying information like our full names, email address, and physical address, sharing that post with approximately 98,000 followers on Instagram via Instagram stories, and reporting content on our Instagram profile that did not contain copyrighted material or any reference to the disputed fairy wing design. We believe that 1) the works are not substantially similar due to the numerous differences between them in both shape and vein pattern, and 2) that the work contains non-protectable elements of nature, specifically from the Papilio xuthus and Graphium nomius butterflies. There are a number of differences between the two designs in both shape and vein pattern, rendering them not substantially similar. The Hey Ricochet Design features one wing in one solid panel, creating two panels total in a set. In contrast, the wings of Jarman’s design are broken into two distinct panels, creating four panels total in a set. The edges of the Hey Ricochet Design are rounded and less dramatic than the Jarman Design. Additionally, the lowermost corner of the wing on the Hey Ricochet Design is short with a round and flared tail. In contrast, the edges of Jarman’s design are sharp with each wing having a narrow uppermost corner on the top panel and a long, pointed lowermost corner on the bottom panel. The arrangement of the veins and the edges they create also has distinguishing elements in the two designs.
In addition to the multiple visual differences in both shape and vein pattern between the two designs, it should be noted for the board that most fairy wing designs are modeled after butterfly, moth, and dragonfly wings, which are non-protectable elements of nature. In the case of the Jarman Design, the bottom portions, or hindwings, appear to be modeled off of Papilio xuthus (Fig. 2) and Graphium nomius (Fig. 3). Due to the appearance in nature, we believe the hindwing shape is not a protectable element.
CLAIM: “The reported content infringes [her] design rights because the wing design is substantially similar to [her] Titania Fairy Wings design with only 2 small veins changed / removed” RESPONSE: There are a number of differences between the two designs in both shape and vein pattern, rendering them not substantially similar. The Hey Ricochet Design features one wing in one solid panel, creating two panels total in a set. In contrast, the wings of Jarman’s design are broken into two distinct panels, creating four panels total in a set. The edges of the Hey Ricochet Design are rounded and less dramatic than the Jarman Design. Additionally, the lowermost corner of the wing on the Hey Ricochet Design is short with a round and flared tail. In contrast, the edges of Jarman’s design are sharp with each wing having a narrow uppermost corner on the top panel and a long, pointed lowermost corner on the bottom panel. The arrangement of the veins and the edges they create also has distinguishing elements in the two designs. First, there are two veins identified by Jarman in her claim that are present in the Jarman Design and not present in the Hey Ricochet Design. Six additional differences are as follows and will be identified with corresponding numbers in Fig. 1: 1. An innermost vein on the upper portion of the wing is present in only the Titania Design; 2. The outer vein of the Hey Ricochet Design connects three veins merging together, which are unconnected in the Jarman Design; 3. The edges of the Hey Ricochet design are three identical hook shapes in this portion, but irregular in the same portion of the Jarman Design; 4. 5. 6. This vein is not present in the Jarman Design; These veins do not intersect or touch in the Hey Ricochet Design; and This vein is not present in the Hey Ricochet Design.
When responding to the takedown notices on our sales platforms, we believed as we do now that the works were not substantially similar. Because the Hey Ricochet Design had been drawn by us independently, we responded as such to the notices.
CLAIM: “The reported content harms [her] market as [she] also makes hair accessories & combs with [her] own wing designs on them. The reported content infringes on and competes with [her] own work, and creates confusion among the public about the origin of the design.” RESPONSE: A review of Jarman’s Instagram account, under the profile name @fancyfairyangela, where she posts about available products and drops, shows that while she has previously made hair accessories, the last time she advertised these products was nearly 4.5 years ago in January of 2021. As seen in Fig. 4, Jarman’s hair combs and the Hey Ricochet design have numerous visual differences and are not substantially similar in design. Despite claims that the Hey Ricochet design “harms [Jarman’s] ability to sell [her] own hair accessories using this design,” in the 7 months since beginning these proceedings and working to have the Hey Ricochet Design removed from sales platforms, Jarman has not made any hair accessories available for sale. Jarman is not currently in the hair accessory market and has not been for more than 4 years. The hair combs Jarman did have for sale in 2020 and 2021, shown as Fig. 4, are distinctly different from the Hey Ricochet design and bear so many differences that an ordinary reasonable person would not conclude they are from the same maker. See Fig. 5 for a comparison of the hair comb designs showing they do not appear substantially similar.