Claim Response

Go to case details

Response details

Heather Firca D/B/A MilMie Designs
Lake Bluff, IL

Representative

Manon Burns
mburns@awglaw.com
312-784-3018
230 W. Monroe St.
Suite 1405
Chicago, IL 60606
Respondent Heather Firca ("Respondent") owns an Etsy shop, MilMie Designs, where she offers for sale original clothing designs. Respondent has been on Etsy since 2021. She is a disabled woman who started the business to contribute meaningfully to society because she is unable to work outside of the home. Respondent has built a strong reputation within the Etsy community and takes great pride in her original work. Respondent also maintains positive relationships with fellow sellers and has never had any problems with any other shop on Etsy. In 2021, in anticipation of the Halloween season, Respondent created and posted for sale an original design consisting of the stacked words "SHAKE SHAKE SHAKE SENORA," as also shown in the attached documentation. Respondent has never claimed rights in the words themselves, but rather the creative expression of her original design. She designed its layout and presentation in a design application, inspired by the movie Beetlejuice. In particular, she selected a large font to occupy the entire shirt to express boisterous yelling, along with a rough vintage appearance because the movie is from 1988. Ms. Firca’s shirt design has become a best seller on Etsy, leading many others to directly copy her creative expression to capitalize on its success. A photograph showing metadata indicating Ms. Firca's creation of the design in 2021 through the GoDaddy Studio is included as evidence. In June of 2024, Respondent submitted a good faith DMCA takedown against Claimant's Etsy posting of a substantially similar design, which appeared to Respondent to be indistinguishable to her design, consisting of the same layout and substantially similar font, as also shown in the attached documentation. Ms. Firca's sole purpose in submitting the takedown request was to safeguard her intellectual property, not to gain an unfair market advantage or "eliminate a competitor" as alleged by Claimant. Rather than file a counter-notice and explain its alleged position of non-infringement to Etsy, Claimant chose to send letters to Respondent. True and correct copies of correspondence between counsel for Claimant and Respondent have been included in this response. In its response to Claimant's letter, Respondent explained that its DMCA notice was submitted in good faith based on the belief that Claimant's design copied the protected creative elements of Respondent's design. Respondent also welcomed any additional evidence provided by Claimant showing that Claimant independently created the design without access to Respondent's design, and Respondent encouraged Claimant to proceed through the counter-notice process with Etsy to provide that evidence, if any. In follow up correspondence, Claimant alleged that it independently created its work in 2023. Respondent withdrew its Etsy complaint on July 11, 2024. Respondent never "admitted she did not have authority to file a DMCA takedown," as claimed in Claimant's Amended Claim. On information and belief, Claimant did not file a counter-notice until July 17, 2024, after Respondent had already retracted its complaint. Claimant appears to claim that its listing has remained down, but this is Claimant's choice. Claimant could have had the listing reinstated within two weeks of the original notice by filing a counter-notice including evidence of independent creation. Alternatively, the listing could have been immediately reinstated after Respondent's retraction of the complaint. Instead, Claimant's decision to keep the listing down appears to be an intentional act to support a frivolous claim aimed at financial gain. As further evidence, Respondent has attached a report from the Etsy portal showing the listing status of the work as "Not Removed." On information and belief, Claimant's claim that a copyright strike remains on their Etsy account due Respondent is false. Once Respondent retracted the copyright claim, any associated strike would have been removed by Etsy. If Claimant is referring to other strikes on its account, those strikes would be due to other copyright infringement claims against Claimant by third parties.
Respondent submitted a good faith takedown request to Etsy based on the belief that Complainant's design copied the protected creative elements of Ms. Firca’s design.
Respondent has a good faith belief that it owns the protectable elements of the creative expression of its design.
Claimant appears to claim that its listing has remained down, but this is Claimant's choice. Claimant could have had the listing reinstated within two weeks of the original notice by filing a counter-notice including evidence of independent creation. Alternatively, the listing could have been immediately reinstated after Respondent's retraction of the complaint. Instead, Claimant's decision to keep the listing down appears to be an intentional act to support a frivolous claim aimed at financial gain.