Claim

Go to case details

Claim details

A claim for infringement
No
Angela M Jarman
fancyfairyangela
Richmond, CA

Authorized representative information

Angela M Jarman
Richmond, CA
11:11 Digital
Titania Fairy Wings
Angela Maria Jarman
Yes
VA2020456
11/23/2015
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
2D fairy wing design
Titania Fairy Wings
Angela Maria Jarman
Yes
VA2020456
11/23/2015
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
2D fairy wing design
Publicly display the work
Create a derivative work
Reproduce the work
Yes
12/10/2019 - Present
https://twitter.com/ParisHilton/status/1204542423642148864 https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=572739053590325 https://twitter.com/ParisHilton/status/1337572289798270976
My own photos of my design were used in image edits and displayed on 11:11 Digital / Paris Hilton's social media accounts without my permission. The same IP, Titania Fairy Wings, has actually been infringed 3 different times by Paris Hilton / 11:11 Digital. The first time I became aware of one on Instagram, I sent a DMCA notice to Paris' company, at management@parishiltonentertainment.com on 9/17/2020 for the Sept. 2020 infringement, as that was the one I became aware of first, requesting removal of the infringing work from Paris' Instagram account. I received no response, but it was removed roughly a week later after gaining over at least 800,000 views. That content used the wing image directly from my listing graphic for the digital overlays I sell for the purpose of photo editing, seen in my store here: https://fancy-fairy-wings-things.myshopify.com/products/titania-fairy-wings-transparency-stock-png-files An error is showing for the documents I'm trying to attach which show how my work was used, but you can see more details in a blog post I made about it here: https://www.fancyfairy.com/news/2020/9/17/infringement-is-not-hot-paris-hilton The 2nd time I noticed an infringement, was in early December 2020. This image used the same IP, from an older image of my work that appeared on my old website and on social media and had been illegally edited and distributed as stock years ago by someone on Deviant Art. I sent a DMCA on 12/12, again asking for removal. This time I received a response from someone named Megan Fargo who claimed to be from Paris Hilton Digital. They stated that a fan made the edits, that they found my fairy wings image on a free clip art site, but did not remove the infringing content. I tried sending a dmca to Instagram for the content, not expecting them to actually remove it as their reporting system is inconsistent and tends to favor large accounts, however they did remove the infringing post for copyright infringement. I sent a dmca for the same infringing image on her Facebook page and one to Twitter, but the dmca was refused on both of those services so the content has remained up. I again wrote a blog post with details of the infringement, which you can see here: https://www.fancyfairy.com/news/2020/12/12/thats-not-hot-paris-part-2-copyright-hullabaloo I learned of the 3rd infringement on April 10 of this year, although this one was actually the oldest. Since my previous request for removal was ignored, I did not send a dmca for the one I found in April. This used the same wing image as the December 2020 infringement. I believe some of these posts may have been monetized with Facebook Watch and Twitter & Instagram bonus systems.
No
The use of my IP by Paris Hilton companies has harmed my market, by exposing it to potentially millions of people without my name attached. My infringements of this IP have increased greatly in the last 3 years but especially in the last 2. I believe these infringements played a part in that by giving Paris' viewers the impression that my IP is a freely available work to use should they find it being distributed (illegally) online. I believe it may also be causing brand confusion between myself and a competing fairy wing maker, HelloFaerie, who engaged in slandering me a few years ago when she was trying to compete in the market. HelloFaerie has been providing Paris with her fairy wings for the last 2 or 3 years. Her business was built upon the foundation my work created. Since these infringements, I have been incorrectly credited or tagged as the wing maker in posts showing HelloFaerie's work quite a few times. This has been adding insult to injury. I am seeking roughly $12,000 in relief, based on previous copyright settlements for online displays of my work and due to the frequency with which the same IP has been infringed by Paris / 11:11 Digital.