Claim

Go to case details

Claim details

A claim for infringement
A claim for misrepresentation under 17 U.S.C. 512(f)
No
Kelly King
Retro Repeats
union, KY

Authorized representative information

Kelly King
Self-represented party
union, KY
Liza Lambertini
Noel Pixies
Kelly King
Yes
VA0002505815
05/10/2026
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
Set of 4 sculptures that are pixie figurines where the body shape spells out noel
Love Pixies
Kelly King
Yes
VA0002510684
05/06/2026
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
Set of 4 sculptured figurines with the body shape that spells out love
Distribute copies of the work
Create a derivative work
Reproduce the work
Yes
Feb 15, 2026 - Present

The alleged infringement has occurred primarily through Facebook, including the Respondent's business page, Art by Liza Lambertini Sangermano, where she has advertised, displayed, offered for sale, and sold sculptures that I allege reproduce protected elements of my original copyrighted NOEL and LOVE Pixie sculptures.

The Respondent has used Facebook posts and product photographs to promote and commercially distribute these allegedly infringing works.

The physical locations where the Respondent manufactured and reproduced the sculptures are not yet fully known. I believe the infringing activities remain ongoing.

No

The Respondent had direct knowledge of my original NOEL Pixie sculptures no later than December 2025, when she placed an order for a set of  NOEL Pixie figurines through my Etsy shop, Retro Repeats. That order was subsequently canceled per her request.

The order demonstrates that the Respondent had viewed and was familiar with my sculptural designs before offering her disputed versions in 2026.

My original NOEL and LOVE Pixie sculptures were also publicly displayed and offered for sale through my Etsy shop beginning in 2025, making photographs of both works accessible to the Respondent.

I possess Etsy transaction records and related communications documenting the Respondent's prior awareness of my work.

My original NOEL and LOVE Pixie sculptures have been publicly displayed, marketed, and sold through my Etsy shop, Retro Repeats (retrorepeatshop.etsy.com), since 2025.

My product listings contain multiple detailed photographs showing the original three-dimensional sculptural designs, including the characters' facial features, body proportions, poses, and letter-shaped forms.

These listings are publicly accessible to Etsy shoppers and have resulted in documented customer purchases. My original sculptures have also been displayed through online promotional content, making the designs available to individuals beyond my existing customers.

The Respondent had the opportunity to view these publicly available sculptural designs before offering her disputed versions in 2026.

I possess dated Etsy listing records, sales history, and product photographs establishing the public availability of my sculptures before the alleged infringement.

The Respondent's NOEL and LOVE Pixie figurines reproduce substantially similar elements of my original copyrighted three-dimensional sculptures.

The similarities concern the underlying sculptural designs, not merely the paint colors, decorative finishes, or general vintage-inspired appearance.

The disputed sculptures share distinctive combinations of character proportions, body shapes, facial features, poses, limb positioning, and sculptural arrangements present in my original works.

My original NOEL and LOVE Pixies incorporate individually sculpted characters into letter-shaped figurines. The Respondent's versions reproduce substantially similar combinations of these distinctive sculptural elements, including the overall forms and character arrangements.

Although certain surface details, colors, or finishes may differ, I allege that the Respondent's works retain protected expressive elements of my original sculptures.

My NOEL and LOVE Pixie sculptures were independently sculpted and first commercially offered in 2025, before the Respondent's disputed versions appeared in 2026.

I possess original sculpting records, dated photographs, copyright registrations, sales documentation, and comparative images supporting these allegations. These materials can demonstrate the specific sculptural similarities between the original and allegedly infringing works.

The Respondent, Liza Lambertini, has reproduced, advertised, offered for sale, and commercially distributed figurines that I allege unlawfully reproduce protected sculptural elements of my original NOEL Pixies and LOVE Pixies.

I independently sculpted these original three-dimensional works in 2025 and hold U.S. copyright registrations VA 2-505-815 (NOEL Pixies) and VA 2-510-684 (LOVE Pixies).

Beginning in approximately February 2026 for the Love and  March 2026 for the Noel, the Respondent began promoting and selling disputed versions of these sculptures through her Facebook business page, Art by Liza Lambertini Sangermano.

Her versions reproduce distinctive combinations of my original characters' sculpted body shapes, proportions, facial features, poses, and overall three-dimensional arrangements. These similarities concern the underlying sculptures, not simply paint colors or shared vintage styling.

I have never granted the Respondent permission to reproduce, mold, manufacture, distribute, or commercially sell copies or derivative versions of my copyrighted sculptures.

Despite my copyright enforcement efforts, I believe the Respondent has continued advertising and offering the disputed works for sale.

I seek relief for the alleged unauthorized reproduction, creation of derivative works, and commercial distribution of my copyrighted sculptural designs.

No

The Respondent's unauthorized reproduction and commercial sale of my original NOEL and LOVE Pixie sculptures have caused financial harm to my business, Retro Repeats.

I invested substantial time, artistic skill, labor, and resources into independently sculpting, developing, and bringing these original works to market in 2025.

The Respondent's allegedly infringing products compete with my original sculptures, potentially diverting customers and sales from my business while allowing the Respondent to commercially benefit from sculptural designs I developed.

The continued reproduction, advertising, and sale of these works have also disrupted my business, required substantial time to document and address the infringement, and interfered with my ability to focus on production and customer orders.

I request statutory damages for infringement of my registered NOEL and LOVE Pixie sculptures under 17 U.S.C. § 504 and the applicable Copyright Claims Board provisions, up to the maximum amount legally permitted based on the registration dates of the works.

Alternatively, I request actual damages and any attributable profits of the Respondent supported by the evidence, subject to the Board's limits.

I will provide supporting copyright registrations, dated sculpting records, sales documentation, evidence of the Respondent's commercial activities, and financial records as appropriate during the proceeding.

Etsy, Inc. (Etsy.com), the online marketplace hosting Retro Repeats' product listings

Nov. 4, 2026

The Respondent submitted DMCA copyright infringement complaints to Etsy targeting three NOEL figurine sets sculpted, designed, created, and sold by Claimant under the business name Retro Repeats.

Claimant's original NOEL Pixie sculptural designs were completed and first offered for sale in 2025, prior to the Respondent's disputed copyright claims. Claimant holds a U.S. copyright registration protecting the original NOEL Pixie artwork.

The Respondent's complaints alleged that Claimant's Etsy listings infringed the Respondent's copyrights. Etsy acted upon the complaints and removed three of Claimant's NOEL product listings, preventing further sales through those listings.

Claimant alleges that the Respondent knowingly and materially misrepresented copyright infringement, causing the wrongful removal of Claimant's original products and resulting commercial harm.

Claimant seeks relief under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) and will provide supporting documentation, including copyright records, dated sales history, Etsy takedown notices, and evidence concerning the Respondent's claims.

Yes
Nov 4, 2026

On November 4, 2026, I submitted a formal DMCA counter-notice to Etsy disputing the removal of three Retro Repeats NOEL product listings.

In submitting the counter-notice, I certified under penalty of perjury that I had a good-faith belief the material was removed or disabled by mistake or misidentification. I also consented to the applicable federal court jurisdiction and service-of-process requirements.

Etsy confirmed by email dated November 4, 2026, at 2:50 PM that it had reviewed and processed my counter-notice and forwarded a copy to the original complainant.

The counter-notice covered Etsy listing IDs 4602603931, 4602625134, and 4596383614.

The Respondent, Liza Lambertini, submitted DMCA copyright infringement complaints to Etsy identifying her claimed intellectual property as "Vintage style NOEL pixies copyright," citing U.S. Copyright Registration No. VAu 1-592-945, and alleging infringement by three of my original NOEL Pixie product listings.

I allege that the Respondent knowingly and materially misrepresented that my original sculptures infringed her copyright.

I independently sculpted my original NOEL Pixie figurines and began selling them in 2025, before the Respondent's disputed copyright claims. My original sculptural work is protected by my own U.S. Copyright Registration No. VA 2-505-815, which identifies me as the author of the sculptures and records their first publication in 2025.

On October 31, 2026, I submitted copyright infringement reports to Facebook concerning the Respondent's unauthorized reproductions of my original pixie sculptures. Shortly afterward, the Respondent filed copyright infringement complaints against my Etsy listings.

I believe the timing of these complaints, following my copyright enforcement actions against her, supports an inference that the Respondent's notices were retaliatory rather than submitted in good faith.

The Respondent's allegations resulted in Etsy removing three of my established product listings: 4602603931, 4602625134, and 4596383614.

These removals prevented customers from purchasing the affected products, disrupted my established business operations, and caused commercial harm.

I contend that the Respondent knowingly misrepresented infringement of her asserted copyright in connection with my independently sculpted, previously published, and registered works. I seek relief under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f).

I possess supporting documentation establishing my copyright ownership, prior sculpting and sales, the Respondent's copyright claims, the chronology of enforcement actions, Etsy's removal notices, and resulting business disruption.

Yes
11/04/2026

As a direct result of the Respondent's allegedly knowing and materially false DMCA infringement complaints, Etsy removed three established product listings from my business, Retro Repeats, on or before November 4, 2026.

These listings offered my original, independently sculpted NOEL Pixie figurines, which I have commercially sold since 2025. The removal prevented customers from purchasing these products through the affected listings during an important holiday shopping period.

The takedowns disrupted my business operations, interrupted potential sales, required me to divert time from producing and fulfilling customer orders, and forced me to spend time preparing counter-notices, communicating with Etsy, documenting the complaints, and pursuing corrective action.

I allege that the Respondent's complaints were retaliatory, following my October 31, 2026 copyright enforcement actions against her Facebook content.

I request monetary relief under 17 U.S.C. § 512(f) for actual damages, including provable lost profits, reasonable costs incurred as a result of the wrongful removals, and other recoverable financial losses directly attributable to the Respondent's alleged misrepresentations.

I will provide supporting records documenting the affected listings, historical sales, duration of removal, business losses, and related expenses. I request that monetary relief be determined based on the evidence presented and within the Copyright Claims Board's applicable limits.