Claim

Go to case details

Claim details

A claim for infringement
No
Angela M Jarman
Richmond, CA

Authorized representative information

Angela M Jarman
Self-represented party
Richmond, CA
Maria Logan
Fancy Fairy Iridescent Bee Fairy Wings Stock
Angela M Jarman
Yes
VA2153442
06/10/2019
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
Isolated 2D bee wing graphic
Titania Fairy Wings
Angela M Jarman
Yes
VA2020456
11/23/2015
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
Fairy wing design
Publicly display the work
Create a derivative work
Reproduce the work
Distribute copies of the work
Unknown
05/01/2018 - Unknown

The infringements were sold within the Second Life™ platform in-world, as well as on the Second Life online Marketplace.

No

I know for certain the respondent saw at least subject art #2, the Fancy Fairy Iridescent Bee Fairy Wings Stock, as she purchased it from my Etsy store on March 17, 2007. The Terms of Use specifically prohibit the use of the stock / overlays in Second Life™, which the respondent violated.

The subject design #1, Titania Fairy Wings, was available in Second Life™ since July 2007, and was re-released in SL to take advantage of the new SL skeleton with wing bones, aka 'Bento Bones' in November of 2017 just a few months after she purchased the Bee Fairy Wings stock from me and almost a year before the earliest known evidence of the infringement.

Although SL Marketplace listings unfortunately don't show the original list dates, reviews offer some sense of time frame. This shows many of the products in my SL store with the Titania name although the oldest ones have been de-listed:
https://marketplace.secondlife.com/stores/13225/search?utf8=%E2%9C%93&search%5Bkeywords%5D=titania&search%5Bcategory_id%5D=&search%5Bmaturity_level%5D=GMA

This design was also seen by millions of people in the H&M Happy & Merry holiday commercial campaign in November 2015 on TV and online, with Katy Perry wearing them dressed as a fairy. Her instagram post inviting followers to see her as a 'festive fairy' garnered over 300K likes, which likely translates to far more actual views:
https://youtu.be/vMWlnHHh-xU?si=-ksSSmgrcnk8J36V

https://thinksweeney.com/hm-holiday-campaign-reveal-on-instagram-achieves-significant-engagement/

https://www.marieclaire.com/culture/news/a17136/katy-perry-hm-holiday-ad/

https://www.nylon.com/articles/katy-perry-holiday-hm-holiday-commercial

My photos of this design have also been copied without my permission thousands of times online on various websites and across social media since its creation.

 

The Titania fairy wings (subject design #1) have been copied almost exactly, except for very minor differences such as a curl being put into the upper tip and the tail. However I've also created and sold a version in real life with curled tips & tails as well, naming them 'Titania Grande', as shown in Exhibit A.

The Bee Fairy Wings (subject design #2) were actually copied straight from my files, but with some color editing to wash out a lot of the highlight & shadow details, before being warped and applied to a slightly differently shaped 3D mesh, and sold as a texture, as shown in Exhibit B. All I had to do was apply the same color adjustments and some warping to show the exact same highlights and shadows are still visible, proving they were used and in violation of the TOU for the stock overlays she purchased. 

The Titania Fairy Wings (subject design #1) copied by Maria (aka Katz Republic in Second Life™, with Bad Katz as the store name) were sold with mesh 'pixie' statues with full permissions, meaning they could be resold by the customer. 
The Bee Fairy Wings stock (subject design #2) was copied with some alterations, and then sold in a texture set for her mesh fairy statues as well as used in the finished statues. Some of the statues were sold full perm as well.

No

As the infringing products were sold with full permissions by Maria, it expanded the infringement to her customers as well, creating even more infringing content. Statements made by her customers describe these items being used 'by hundreds of creators' across the grid (see Exhibit C).

There were some terms that forbid them from being sold as-is, such as requiring that the customers make changes to the textures before reselling the 'pixie' statues with the offending wings. However, since the wings' look copied from the Titania design came entirely from the 3D mesh rather than a painted texture and could be separated and removed from the statue, this made a great variety of products to be made with them.

These infringements may cause potential new customers to assume that the works are public domain and free to copy themselves.
Further, Maria has engaged in defamation in retaliation for reporting and having the infringing content removed.
She has not only lied about not being familiar with my work, but also falsely stated that I 'threatened' and 'harassed' her customers (see Exhibit C), that I'm "a mentally disturbed individual, possibly even drunk or having paranoid delusions as a result of drugs".
I believe these infringements were done willfully, which my evidence supports, and the notecard distributed to her store group with the quoted statements meant to harm my business.

Since Maria has filed a counter notice, forcing me to escalate this to a legal claim in order to protect my IP, after engaging in libel & defamation of character, I will be seeking monetary relief. However, I would like to first learn how much she's profited off of the infringing content before making a specific request.

I should note that I've been contacted by a 3rd party who stated that Maria infringed on their IP as well, and that they believed Maria has been obtaining her 3D meshes from other asset sites such as TurboSquid and CG Trader, likely also violating their terms. A screenshot of those statements are visible in Exhibit C.