Claim

Go to case details

Claim details

A claim for infringement
No
Angela M Jarman
RICHMOND, CA

Authorized representative information

Angela M Jarman
Richmond, CA
SHEIN Distribution Corporation
Teasel Fairy Wings
Angela Maria Jarman
Yes
VA2067020
06/10/2016
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
2D fairy wing design
Titania Fairy Wings
Angela Maria Jarman
Yes
VA2020456
11/23/2015
Pictorial Graphic and Sculptural (such as two-dimensional and three-dimensional works of art, graphic art, and photographs)
2D fairy wing design
Publicly display the work
Reproduce the work
Distribute copies of the work
Yes
unknown - Present
Infringement occurs on their US web store at these listings: https://us.shein.com/50pcs-Scenery-Pattern-Random-Material-Paper-p-5917587-cat-2272.html?share_from=iosshus&url_from=GM7268194067147595776&ref=www&rep=dir&ret=us and https://us.shein.com/50pcs-Mixed-Pattern-Sticker-p-2766489-cat-2272.html?src_identifier=st%3D2%60sc%3Dfairy%60sr%3D0%60ps%3D1&src_module=search&src_tab_page_id=page_search1657396187749&attr_ids=&scici=Search~~EditSearch~~1~~fairy~~~~0
My photos of my fairy wings creations were used without permission and reproduced as stickers in a booklet that SHEIN is selling on their website. A friend recognized one of them and messaged me to ask if it was my photo, and indeed it was my photo from my Titania Painted Fairy Wings Etsy listing, the copper / rose gold colored one as seen here: https://www.etsy.com/listing/171521829/titania-iridescent-fairy-wings-with?show_sold_out_detail=1&ref=nla_listing_details. She sent me the listing (1st url provided above in previous section) and there I could see small thumbnail photos, of my Titania wings and also my green painted Teasel Fairy Wings. I'll call that one Sticker Book A. The photo of my Teasel Fairy Wings design can be seen in my old Etsy listing here: https://www.etsy.com/listing/60733733/teasel-iridescent-fairy-wings-with They're selling those sticker booklets containing my Titania and Teasel fairy wing photos for $2, described as '50pcs Scenery Pattern Random Material Paper'. So far it has 1773 customer reviews, indicating at least that many purchases. I then found another sticker book listing containing the same Teasel Fairy Wings photo that is in the first sticker book. That listing is the second link provided above in the 'where the alleged infringing acts occurred'. I'll call this one Sticker Book B. It's listed as '50pcs Mixed Pattern Sticker'. That item has 2441 customer reviews and is being sold for $1.50 each. Both of these properties are wing designs that I sell digital overlays for on my website currently and used to sell physical wearable versions of, however they use different photos. I have never sold to SHEIN and even if they did purchase the overlays, this use violates my terms of use as I do NOT allow commercial use such as this where the stand-alone image of the wings is distributed in any format. In addition, SHEIN features models on their website and on their Instagram wearing what I can identify as knock-offs of my Titania Fairy Wings design. They don't appear to be made by me, as I can see small differences in the construction that never appeared in my own work. For example, in these listings: https://us.shein.com/ROMWE-Fairy-Grunge-Allover-Mushroom-Print-Frill-Trim-Shirred-Cami-Dress-p-10292813-cat-1727.html?src_identifier=st%3D2%60sc%3Dgrunge%20fairy%60sr%3D0%60ps%3D1&src_module=search&src_tab_page_id=page_goods_detail1657513343041&attr_ids=&scici=Search~~EditSearch~~1~~grunge_20fairy~~~~0 https://us.shein.com/ROMWE-Fairy-Grunge-Floral-Print-Ruffle-Hem-Cami-Dress-p-10292653-cat-1727.html?src_identifier=st%3D2%60sc%3Dgrunge%20fairy%60sr%3D0%60ps%3D1&src_module=search&src_tab_page_id=page_goods_detail1657513343041&attr_ids=&scici=Search~~EditSearch~~1~~grunge_20fairy~~~~0 The knock-off wing copies also appear in this Instagram post: https://www.instagram.com/p/CfhYe88vuPw/
No
I am the only company that sells these fairy wings designs in any format, and did not license SHEIN to sell these images. SHEIN is profiting off of my IPs without permission or payment to me, which deprives me of potential licensing income from my own IP. The sales of my images as cheap stickers dilutes their value, and when in addition they're displaying models wearing knock-offs of those designs, it implies to the public that I am collaborating with their company somehow when I am absolutely not. In fact, I would not choose to work with this company as the entire economy of 'fast fashion' and the negative impact it has on the environment conflicts with my values. I am seeking the maximum amount of damages that the CCB deems I should be awarded, should they decide in my favor.